ᐅ Opinion on the House Design

Created on: 20 May 2016 00:30
R
reeneex
Hello to all interested readers,

For about half a year now, my wife and I have been planning our new home. We have found a nice plot of land and have also decided on the building style (Ytong kit house). Initial contact with the company has been made.
Now the first draft from their architect has arrived, and we find it far from satisfactory.

Our goal is a KfW 40+ house on a slope, with a slight incline of about 3m (10 feet) over the first 5m (16 feet) in depth, then another 2m (7 feet) incline over the remaining 30m (98 feet) of depth.

- Front side facing southwest
- Lower floor planned as a full story, possibly to be converted into an apartment later. At the moment, it will be used as a guest room and office
- Roof of the office = terrace

Garage as an attached structure with a flat roof.
I’ve attached some pictures. The draft itself was created with MeinHeim3D V3. Unfortunately, I can’t upload that here. I also have plans in PDF if that helps.

The architect says that our draft is unfavorable because of the protruding office and the garage. This would be bad from an energy perspective.
Now I am under the impression that with good insulation, a lot can be achieved and that with KfW 40+ the final energy value counts, so I can compensate for some losses in the building envelope by the technology used.

Am I seeing this wrong?

3D house model with brown shingle roof; opened exterior wall shows staircase and interior.

3D house model with terrace, wooden doors, wooden windows, and garage on green ground.

Two-story house with dark roof, terrace, exterior stairs on grassy platform in the sky.

3D house on grass plateau at cliff edge; grey two-story house with brown roof.
K
kbt09
7 Nov 2016 06:23
reeneex schrieb:
The staircase is designed by the architect. It was the only U-shaped one in the plan.

That’s why I pointed out that the hallway, measuring 320 x 342 cm (126 x 135 inches), seems too small if a cloakroom is also to be included there. Even the architect can hardly change that.
Climbee7 Nov 2016 08:49
I would also reduce the size of the bathroom on the ground floor in favor of the hallway. Wouldn't a shower bathroom be enough for the child? If they want to use the bathtub occasionally, they can also use the parents' bathroom, right?
To make this work, you might need to swap the kitchen and bathroom.
R
reeneex
7 Nov 2016 09:03
The architect is responsible for the staircase. How they solve it is their problem. We are waiting to see what they decide. The kitchen must stay there. One children’s room is enough; mine was even smaller and I turned out fine.
L
Legurit
7 Nov 2016 09:27
As a child, I would have been grateful if everyone ALWAYS passed by my room.
Otherwise, happy to have a living room with peepholes, but the main thing is 4 (!) toilets?!
Please start over.
R
reeneex
7 Nov 2016 09:35
Everyone is entitled to their own opinion.
RobsonMKK7 Nov 2016 09:37
Do you, as parents, sometimes have visitors in the evening? Or watch a movie that can be a bit louder?
How old is your child? With a bedroom like that, I would have taken the opportunity and basically slipped away regularly.