ᐅ L-Shaped Floor Plan – What Are Your Thoughts?

Created on: 22 Mar 2020 23:12
Y
Ypsi aus NI
Y
Ypsi aus NI
22 Mar 2020 23:12
Hello dear forum members,

as mentioned in the introduction thread, here is the current status of our house planning.
The plot is located in the second row and is accessible via the courtyard of the front house (shared driveway).
Currently, there are existing buildings on the plot that need to be demolished.

We have already had a few planning discussions with construction companies, and honestly, I have to say I am shocked by their “professionalism.” We have now specifically selected companies where consultation takes place with architects and not, for example, a trained cook (no joke, that actually happened!). In addition, we are already annoyed by the question: “What do you want to build? A shell bungalow or a single-family house?” When we say: “Let’s work out the floor plan step by step and see which shape and roof pitch result, then we can still decide the official house type,” we only get strange looks. There were no independent ideas tailored to the plot... When asking what they would recommend, we just get a questioning look. I have to say, I expected more, but maybe it is normal that you have to bring the initial idea for the floor plan yourself...

Due to the current situation, further appointments with the construction companies are difficult to arrange. So we are using the time to plan ourselves. After tapping into your collective intelligence in the first step, we will then send our draft to the companies including the issues we still see. They will then have the chance to optimize and price our draft for the next consultation.
For us, the heart of the house is the ground floor; the upper floor follows from the ground floor plan (room layout, bathroom above utility room, windows, etc.). The upper floor is located on the exterior walls of the ground floor to the right (north) and bottom (east) of the plan, while to the left (south) and top (west) it is limited to the “main rectangle” or recessed by 1.5m (roughly 5 feet).

Attached you will find the completed questionnaire. Unanswered questions I have not included anymore.

We are very curious about your opinion!

Many thanks in advance.
Ypsi aus NI

Development Plan / Restrictions
Plot size approx. 700 sqm
Floor area ratio (FAR) 0.3
Site coverage ratio 0.3
Building window, building line and boundary 3m (10 feet) from the neighbor’s boundary
Number of floors 1 full story
open development


Client Requirements
Style, roof shape, building type (Mediterranean) urban villa
Basement, floors 1.5 floors
Number of occupants, age 2 people + planned children
Space requirements on ground floor and upper floor GF = 130-140 sqm (1400-1500 sq ft), UF = 50-60 sqm (540-650 sq ft)
Open or closed architecture open
Conservative or modern construction modern
Open kitchen, kitchen island kitchen island
Number of dining seats 6-8
Fireplace wood stove
Balcony, roof terrace possibly roof terrace (flat roof on both volumes)
Garage, carport double garage

House Design
Planned by: Do-it-Yourself
What do you like in particular? Why? Shape fits well into the plot, living area is somewhat separated, kitchen and dining table as central element
What do you dislike? Why? Is the staircase suitable? Is the entrance spacious enough? Can the private rooms on the ground floor be arranged this way?
Preferred heating technology: heat pump

Why did the design develop this way?
We consider the plot relatively narrow. Normally, a rectangular house shape would make sense, using the full width of the plot. But then you lose the best side (south). The floor plan was developed according to “form follows function” and we really like it now (I mean the L-shape, not necessarily the individual room layout).
An interesting idea is not to realize the two wings on the upper floor with a hip roof, but instead to have a flat roof to possibly create one or two roof terraces.
The original wish was for a bungalow, but we realized that it consumes too much floor space. A good compromise for us is to have the master bedroom and master bathroom on the ground floor, and the children’s rooms plus office upstairs.

What is the most important/basic question about the floor plan summarized in 130 characters?
Are there fundamental planning mistakes we have overlooked so far?

Floor plan: open kitchen, dining area, living room, hallway, bathroom, bedroom, utility room, guest WC.


Floor plan of a building with five rooms (Room 1-5) and area information in sqm.


Aerial view of a plot: house with double garage, red marked outline, adjacent street.
Y
Ypsi aus NI
22 Mar 2020 23:14
Oh, and one more thing: We really like the non-traditional floor plan shape. In particular, we are very fond of the angled corners. We currently live in a house with many angled walls, and even after 8 years, we still really like it.
11ant23 Mar 2020 00:40
Upper floor rooms 1 / 3 / 4 are all dedicated to children who are not yet planned? – and the one-and-a-half-story design is supposed to be achieved solely through "extensions" on the ground floor?
https://www.instagram.com/11antgmxde/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/bauen-jetzt/
Y
ypg
23 Mar 2020 00:42
Hello!
What kind of knee wall and what type of hip roof are planned? And where will the double garage be located? What is the second gray area?
Could you please mark and sketch the site plan with the house and driveway? Thanks.
And one more thing: What is the budget for the house alone?
Pinky030123 Mar 2020 06:20
What immediately stands out to me is that the master area starts with the bedroom, making it impossible to continue sleeping peacefully if your partner gets up earlier or vice versa when going to sleep. Having the bed right next to the dining table is probably not ideal in terms of noise either.
F
FloHB123
23 Mar 2020 07:34
Having the bathroom and dressing room accessible only through the bedroom, and then right next to the living room, is not ideal in my opinion.

If there are children, it can get tricky. If one of the parents wants to rest or sleep in during the day, it’s practically impossible because the adjacent room will always be noisy. The same applies if someone wants to go to bed earlier.

By the way, I still don’t understand why anyone would voluntarily build three bathrooms—all of them need to be cleaned after all...