ᐅ Renovation of a Two-Family House from 1936 – Experiences?

Created on: 30 Aug 2022 17:38
L
leschaf
Hello everyone,

We bought a two-family house from 1936 in June. More about the financing can be found in this thread. We are still very happy that we bought it. Our baby is due in December, and once our second child needs their own bedroom, the apartment will become too small. We have also visited the property quite often since then and are very pleased with the location. Everything from daycare to high school is within walking distance, along with plenty of sports clubs, and more.

Since the purchase, quite a bit has happened. Our financing was based on equity and a bank loan for the purchase alone. For the renovation, we planned to use capital from the sale of another property. The sale has now been completed and brought in slightly more than our optimistic estimate (365,000€ vs. 350,000€ optimistic expectation vs. 300,000€ minimum expectation). I have to say that selling caused me more headaches than buying the new house—even though it involved significantly less money. Especially the news about falling prices everywhere unsettled us and made us worry that the buyer might pull out. We did have multiple offers, including two in the same range, but the second highest bidder reacted quite badly to being rejected. That would have meant relisting, which, due to the increased costs of living since the agreement and the age of the house, probably would have led to a lower sale price. Once the notarized contract was signed, we were able to breathe a sigh of relief.

Now the work begins. We already have an architect who we have been consulting with over the past two years while looking at houses. She has so far done all the appointments and planning free of charge and invested a lot of time. We have already met on-site with a heating engineer, electrician, and flooring specialist. All have praised the structural condition and potential of the house so far, which is very reassuring.

Here is a picture of the current exterior from the garden side:



White multi-story house with garden, trees and solar panels on the roof


The house was insulated on the outside with 8cm (3 inches) of external thermal insulation composite system (ETICS) in 1996—but unfortunately, no major energy upgrades have been made since then. According to the energy certificate, the current demand is about 220 kWh/m²/a, which for 187 m² (2,013 sq ft) of living space would mean around 41,000 kWh per year. According to gas bills, however, the consumption in 2020 (the last year it was occupied) was only around 22,000 kWh for two households living there separately. That is still a lot, and of course, we want to modernize it. During the recent heatwave, it was actually cooler in the two full floors than in our already quite cool old apartment, which I see as a good sign. The house itself has cavity solid walls.

This means the following for us:
- Insulation of the top-floor ceiling: The attic has a huge footprint and covers roughly 80% of the developed attic space. Therefore, we decided to insulate the attic floor at first, which is more cost-effective than insulating the entire roof, since we won’t need that space anytime soon.
- Insulation of the basement ceiling
- Elimination of some thermal bridges
- Completely new windows and exterior doors throughout the house

Before buying, the architect said that should reduce the demand to around 150 kWh/m²/a or less, and further optimizations might no longer be cost-effective. Since then, energy costs have changed quite a bit… so we’ll see if we address anything else (would you, for example, recommend adding cavity insulation between the two masonry layers as well? Or would that not work well with the ETICS?). What’s your realistic assessment? I would obviously like to reduce it further, but I would prefer to avoid completely rebuilding the roof.

In addition:
- Replace pipes and wiring throughout the whole house
- New radiators
- Heat pump, if it makes sense / if the house can be heated properly with one
- If heat pump: photovoltaic system (the left side of the roof in the picture faces directly south)

That’s the energy-related part. Several other works are planned as well. This is the current floor plan—the ground floor and first floor are almost identical, but both floors have a nice passage between the two right-side rooms with a sliding door that needs to be preserved:


Floor plan of a house with kitchen, hallway, bathroom, living room, bedroom, and stairs


And the attic floor plan:

Black and white floor plan with several chambers, stairwell, and dimensions.


The rough plan is as follows:

Ground Floor:

Hand-drawn floor plan sketch showing living room, kitchen, dining area, office, hallway, stairs, bathroom.


First Floor:

Hand-drawn floor plan sketch: balcony at top, master bedroom left, 2 children's rooms right, bathroom bottom, hallway.


Since both bathrooms need renewing anyway (photos from inside will follow later), we are moving them to the front, facing the street. This will free up space downstairs to open up the kitchen/dining area and allow a slightly larger bathroom upstairs than currently exists. Right now, we live with a 3 m² (32 sq ft) bathroom—it works for three people but is definitely not very comfortable 😀

I work almost 100% from home, so the office is on the ground floor. The attic layout will remain as is. It will include my partner’s craft/workroom, a guest room, and we have one extra room that is still undecided 🙂. The nice thing is that due to the steep roof, we even have higher ceilings on the attic floor (>2.60 m / 8.5 ft) than on the ground and first floors (2.55 m / 8.4 ft), with very little sloping (photos to follow).

Throughout the house, there are old wooden floorboards hidden under several layers of flooring. Fortunately, none are glued down but simply laid loose, so we already looked underneath with the flooring specialist and found the condition to be good. These floors will be restored rather than replaced! This is also a reason why we don’t want to install underfloor heating—the floorboards are too thick, probably fragile for removal, and underfloor heating would cause a chain reaction: the doors (which we also just want to restore/paint), the frames, and so on, would no longer fit. However, underfloor heating will probably be installed in the bathroom upstairs. The indoor staircase is another beautiful old wooden staircase that was hidden under carpet and will also only be restored as needed.

The architect’s first cost estimate is around 270,000€ for all measures (excluding photovoltaics). The three tradespeople who have been on site have more or less confirmed her rough calculation. Statics engineer and window fitter will visit next week—we’re excited 🙂

Current concerns:
- Can we achieve an energy level that makes a heat pump reasonably economical (we do have a lot of roof space for photovoltaics)?
- Is the rest of the cost estimate realistic?
- What surprises might still be waiting for us?
- When will it be completed? Target is early summer next year...

We look forward to your feedback!
L
leschaf
12 Nov 2022 11:39
K a t j a schrieb:

What are the exact dimensions of the shower? The entrance and overall size look a bit small on the plan. I wouldn’t go below 66cm (26 inches) for entrances and 90x90cm (35x35 inches) for showers. Also, for the main bathroom, I’d check the measurements for both the shower and the bathtub.

The entrance is 76cm (30 inches) wide, the shower is 90x80cm (35x31 inches) – it could be pushed 10cm (4 inches) into the office if needed. I’m not sure if that’s really necessary though. Our current shower is only 60cm (24 inches) wide and feels cramped only because it has a shower tray that narrows at the bottom. At the top, there’s no real issue, so 80cm (31 inches) will probably feel quite spacious to us.

In the main bathroom, the shower is 90x90cm (35x35 inches) and the bathtub is 1.50m (59 inches) long – is that too short? We are 177cm (5 ft 10 in) and 165cm (5 ft 5 in) tall and rather slim/average build (though that might change over the years :P)
K a t j a12 Nov 2022 11:49
leschaf schrieb:

The entrance is 76cm (30 inches) wide, the shower is 90x80cm (35x31 inches) – you could possibly move it 10cm (4 inches) further into the office.

Of course, this is very individual, but if it were mine, I would expand the shower to 90x90cm (35x35 inches) and avoid having a floor-to-ceiling window in the study, so that a sideboard could fit next to the window opening.
leschaf schrieb:

In the main bathroom, the shower is 90x90cm (35x35 inches) and the bathtub is 1.50m (4 ft 11 in) long – too short? We are 177cm (5 ft 9½ in) and 165cm (5 ft 5 in) tall and rather slim/average build (this might change over the years :p)

That is quite a small bathtub. Usually, bathtubs are closer to 1.80m (5 ft 11 in) in length. The problem with such compromises is often that you end up not using them because they are simply uncomfortable.
L
leschaf
12 Nov 2022 12:31
K a t j a schrieb:

That is quite a small bathtub. Usually, they are closer to 1.80m (6 feet) in length. The problem with such makeshift solutions is often that you end up never using them because they’re simply uncomfortable.

Do you have any good ideas on how to fit a longer one? Realistically, the bathroom can only be extended to the left side on the plan, roughly like this:

Floor plan of a bathroom with bathtub, sink, and storage room.


With a bathtub length of 180cm (6 feet), there would only be about 50cm (20 inches) of space left to the toilet. Currently, in our tiny bathroom, we have 45cm (18 inches) to the wall, and that’s already rather uncomfortably tight. How else could it be changed or reorganized? The sink is currently 1m (3 feet 3 inches) wide — we could probably save some space here since we don’t need two faucets; 70cm (28 inches) in width should be enough.
K a t j a12 Nov 2022 13:00
I am missing some important measurements here—especially the door clearances. Is it still possible to adjust their positions? On the original plan, everything looks very tight, and here the door to the storage room seems, in my opinion, somewhat generously shifted to the left side of the plan. Where exactly does the staircase end?

Why is the room on the ground floor 5.31 meters long (17 ft 5 in), while the room directly above on the upper floor is 5.77 meters (18 ft 11 in)? The wall above isn’t that much thinner, is it? Or is there an offset in the chimney? And where exactly is the window located?
K a t j a12 Nov 2022 13:31
Without dimensions, it remains a guessing game. I would think along these lines:


Floor plan of a bathroom with shower, bathtub, sink, toilet, and storage room.
L
leschaf
12 Nov 2022 13:53
I have added the measurements. The red wall will be newly built and can therefore be placed freely. The door on the right side of the plan already exists, while the one on the left is currently planned and could be moved. I would place the boundary on the window side to the left of the plan at the window, as we want to reuse the existing lintels and so on wherever possible.

I still need to check exactly where the staircase ends in the house, but 1.35 meters (4 feet 5 inches) seems about right. The bathroom window currently planned is 1.2 meters (4 feet) wide.