ᐅ Which smart home system is best for our new build?

Created on: 24 Jul 2022 09:48
P
Pacc666
Hello

we are currently building our new house.
We had the first appointment with the electrician, and for the smart home system, he recommended Free@home.

The electrician does not offer KNX.

What would you recommend? Should we go with Free@home or install a wireless smart home system ourselves later?
N
Neubau2022
25 Jul 2022 10:47
squier23 schrieb:

For cost and feasibility reasons, we had to give up wired systems and now I’m doing everything wirelessly myself. Choose a manufacturer-independent control unit (ioBroker, openHAB, HomeAssistant...), then it doesn’t matter if you’re waiting for Matter or which systems you use. For example, I combine Alexa, eufy, Shelly, HomematicIP, Unifi, Aqara and am completely flexible with gadgets.

Doorbird seems Apple-like to me: looks nice and works, but in the end, you pay for the design. So far, I haven’t found a “better” feature set. I initially wanted to work with the new Unifi Doorbell, but it’s sold out forever. I recently got the new eufy Doorbell and I like it. A reaction time of 5 seconds is acceptable for a video doorbell. Certainly no Ring, which additionally costs monthly fees, as already mentioned.

The important thing is that the electrician installs deep mounting boxes so you can retrofit Shelly or similar devices if needed.
P
Pacc666
25 Jul 2022 11:22
Deep flush-mounted boxes (63mm (2.5 inches)) are standard for us.

The Doorbird is quite interesting for us because the cloud service is free, and the Doorbird can be combined with the new ekey Fingerprint sLine flush-mounted fingerprint scanner and doorbell (which looks very high-quality visually).

The new ekey Fingerprint xLine is mounted individually on the facade, and then the Ring, Eufy, or other surface-mounted doorbell is installed separately above it (which doesn’t look as good visually).
N
netuser
25 Jul 2022 11:25
Pacc666 schrieb:

or other surface-mounted doorbell (doesn’t look as good aesthetically)

...at least there are also flush-mounted solutions available from others 😉
N
Neubau2022
25 Jul 2022 12:15
Pacc666 schrieb:

Deep flush-mounted boxes (63mm (2.5 inches)) are standard for us.

The Doorbird is quite interesting for us since the cloud service is free, and the Doorbird can be combined with the new ekey fingerprint sLine flush-mounted unit with the doorbell (which looks very high quality visually).

The new ekey fingerprint xLine is mounted individually on the facade, and above it, a separate Ring, Eufy, or other surface-mounted doorbell is installed (which doesn’t look as good visually).

For me, fingerprint access is similar to a Quooker—nice to have but not essential 😎 The Eufy video doorbell is so small that you can barely see it from a distance. We install it on the concrete pillar of the fence. I’m pretty easygoing about that :-)
P
Pacc666
25 Jul 2022 12:49
There is no flush-mounted version available from Ring, Eufy, or other Wi-Fi doorbells.

At our place, the doorbell is mounted on the facade right next to the front door (so the appearance is quite important).

Does anyone have experience with the Doorbird?
Araknis25 Jul 2022 12:55
Pacc666 schrieb:

Does anyone have experience with the Doorbird?
It works, but in my opinion, it sometimes takes too long for the calls to reach the phone. However, this is common with almost all systems and depends on many factors.