ᐅ Windowpane never replaceable again

Created on: 4 Mar 2016 11:51
P
Peanuts74
A question for any legal experts or people who have had similar experiences.
We have a U-shaped reinforced concrete staircase (double turn without an intermediate landing) from the basement (at street level on the street side) up to the ground floor.
“Behind” the staircase is a window to let in more light in the stairwell, so the lights don’t have to be on during the day.
The window is fixed, meaning it is not designed to open (no handle or anything).
So far, so good. We recently considered installing a partially frosted glass pane to reduce visibility of the staircase from outside. At that point, we realized the glass would likely never be removable because the staircase extends all the way to the wall.

The question now is, is it considered a (hidden) defect if a windowpane cannot be replaced without either seriously damaging the staircase or chipping away part of the interior plaster and masonry?
This is not about the other glass for now, since you could use a film in the basement window. But I wonder who would cover the additional costs if the pane, for example, breaks at some point. As mentioned, the wall above the window would have to be partially opened up to pull the pane out upward.

Thank you very much for any answers, opinions, or possibly similar rulings or legal references...
Musketier25 Apr 2016 17:37
Without a floor plan, it’s a bit difficult to tell, but don’t you have a stairwell opening at that spot?
A
alter0029
25 Apr 2016 17:44
Maybe the top is open and I just didn’t notice. We simply were not given any advice.
Musketier25 Apr 2016 17:58
You should be able to see both the stairwell and the window in the floor plan of the upper floor. No consultation is needed for that.
B
Bauexperte
25 Apr 2016 19:04
@ alter

Of course it is possible; it is located in front of the stairs and is therefore easily accessible.

Bauexperte
B
Bauexperte
19 Jul 2016 21:17
@alter0029 and @NSK GmbH

It is sufficient for you to exchange your differing opinions in one thread. The forum is not a place for your personal dispute and does not want to be!

Please keep this in mind, as the moderators and I will delete any further posts related to your disagreement that are not posted in the original thread.

Regards, Bauexperte