ᐅ New construction of a semi-detached house approximately 8 by 11 meters, assessment of floor plan and windows

Created on: 18 May 2018 12:56
E
espressionist
Hello everyone,

we are currently planning a semi-detached house measuring 8 x 11 m (26 x 36 ft) on a 289 sqm (3,110 sq ft) plot in a new development area (the neighboring house has not been built yet, as the area is still being developed).
We would appreciate your comments on the current floor plans and any tips regarding window planning!

Thank you very much!
Development Plan / Restrictions
Plot size: 289 sqm (3,110 sq ft), approx. 10.3 x 29 m (34 x 95 ft), slightly angled in the southern section
Slope: no
Site coverage ratio: 0.35
Floor area ratio: 0.6
Building envelope, building line and boundaries: The building envelope starts 3 m (10 ft) south of the northern street and is 14 m (46 ft) long. There is an additional building easement (semi-detached house), and the building envelope ends 2.5 m (8 ft) before the eastern dead-end street.
Parking spaces: 2
Orientation: north-south
Other requirements: roof shape (gable roof), roof pitch (34 degrees), and eaves height (6 m / 20 ft) have already been agreed with the neighbors.

Client Requirements
Style, roof shape, building type: classic-modern, gable roof, semi-detached house
Basement, floors: basement, ground floor + upper floor as full stories
Number of occupants, ages: 4 (40, 40, 5, 1)
Ground floor room requirements: kitchen, dining area, living room, study (for occasional home office), WC + shower, cloakroom

Upper floor room requirements: bathroom, master bedroom, 2 children’s bedrooms (preferably similar size)
Office: home office
Guest stays per year: probably rare (2-3 times for 2-3 days)
Open or closed layout: open preferred on the ground floor (kitchen, dining, living areas), otherwise the rooms might feel too small
Open kitchen, kitchen island: open kitchen with a peninsula
Number of dining seats: regularly 6 with our current table (can be extended for up to 4 more seats)
Fireplace: no
Music/sound system wall: in the living room by the TV wall
Balcony, rooftop terrace: no
Garage, carport: carport (6.5 x 4 m / 21 x 13 ft) on the north side. Currently, a 2 x 2.5 m (7 x 8 ft) shed for bicycles, etc. is planned on the west side of the carport. The carport also serves as a covered entrance.
Vegetable garden, greenhouse: we would like to plant a little (e.g. raised bed), but it should not cause stress
Additional wishes / special features / daily routine, also reasons why certain things should or should not be included:

Our requirement for the upper floor was that the parents’ and children’s areas are at least somewhat separated (no shared wall).

This was achieved by the architect through a walk-in closet between the master bedroom and children’s room.

We can hardly do without a basement, as we cannot fit a garage on the plot (due to setback requirements in the development plan, this would force us to make the house narrower or give up too much garden space), and we also have limited space for storage or building services.

Because this results in a nicely sized hobby room in the basement, we decided not to finish the attic (so it will only be a roof space), as we believe we can fit everything else inside.

A finished attic would certainly be nice (guest room, media room, library, etc.) but with estimated additional costs of about 30,000, we prefer to forgo it.

House Design
Planning by: architect of our prefabricated house company
What do you like most? Why? Bedrooms and children’s rooms are adequately sized (previous plans had children’s rooms at 13 sqm / 140 sq ft), office on the ground floor (close to kitchen for coffee breaks), bright dining area
What do you dislike? Why? Windows—the architects’ design in the children’s rooms is okay, but in the master bedroom (window on the north side with the bed partially underneath), in the office (we would like a bookshelf on the north side and desk on the south side to avoid direct light on the monitor; parking space is planned on the east side, so a car would be parked right in front of the window), and bathroom / WC (parapet height too low?) are not completely convincing.
Price estimate from architect/planner: approximately 370,000 (turnkey, with floors already selected by us—we had a preliminary selection)
Personal budget limit for house, including finishing: about 400,000
Preferred heating system: air-to-water heat pump, underfloor heating

If you had to give up something, which details/finishes
- What you can give up: instead of a sliding door to the terrace, a regular door; instead of aluminum-plastic windows, only plastic windows (difference of 4,000); planned premium for a different staircase (7,000); partial wood facade omitted (planned cost 1,500)
- What you cannot give up: house size (should not be smaller)

Why is the design as it is now?

We initially spent several hours with a very friendly consultant from the company to develop a design based on our requirements (office on ground floor, slight separation of parent and children areas, shower on ground floor, basement, carport).

A friend who is an architect made some suggestions, and after an in-depth discussion with us, the company’s architect created the attached floor plan.

We like the floor plan quite well so far (we know that planning a semi-detached house comes with some limitations), but the window planning seems somewhat “old-fashioned” to us.

What is the most important / fundamental question about the floor plan, summarized in 130 characters?

Are there any major flaws in the floor plan that we have not noticed yet?
What would you possibly optimize?
What do you think about the window planning and our suggestions regarding it?

Thank you very much for your help and for the time you spend in this forum.
We appreciate any feedback!

Two-story residential building north view with carport and entrance area

Two-story house with garage; cars in front; group under a tree, boundary street

South facade of a house with photovoltaic roof, windows, glass door and terrace

Floor plan of a single-family house with garden, trees, street and two cars in driveway

Site plan of a building with floor plan, street surroundings and dimensions

Floor plan of a house with rooms, stairs, bathroom, terrace and street access

Sketch of two buildings (south/north) with photovoltaic, windows, doors, cars and people

Sketch of a single-family house with tree on the left, group of people at the front door, car at carport
E
espressionist
30 May 2018 08:12
kbt09 schrieb:
First of all from me as well: great opening, site plan and everything included, it really makes it enjoyable to look at the details.

Thank you.
kbt09 schrieb:
Therefore, just a note that I would also leave the staircase out of the living area. Once because of the basement and then also for the teenager/privacy reasons you mentioned.

What I have learned in this regard: there are quite different approaches. We currently clearly prefer a closed solution, but I understand that with a classic townhouse or a narrow semi-detached house, an open solution is almost unavoidable.
kbt09 schrieb:
And, dressing room, master bedroom and bathroom don’t seem optimal yet; however, off the top of my head, I had no good suggestion.

A change regarding the dressing room is definitely necessary: the wall between dressing room and hallway must be moved at least 10cm (4 inches) toward the hallway. Otherwise, it will probably be difficult to fit an appropriate shelving system on both sides of the door inside the dressing room (for example, the Pax cabinet from Ikea is 58cm (23 inches) deep, which currently would not fit).
kbt09 schrieb:
I would rather do without the corner windows in both the office and the bedroom.

We will do the same. The plan is to have windows only on the east side in both rooms. This way, there will be no window above the bed in the bedroom, and in the office, we would have the entire north wall free for shelving. The desk would then be placed along the south wall. That should be the most favorable in terms of light.
E
espressionist
31 May 2018 16:02
Our architect is currently still on vacation, so it’s not yet clear whether the kitchen and lounge area can be swapped.
Therefore, we are also considering the current plan in parallel.

2D floor plan of a house showing the living room, dining area, and kitchen from above


What we don’t like here is that an L-shaped sofa, as shown, has its back facing the middle of the room, which would visually reduce the space.
It would be better if the sofa were placed in the top right corner of the plan. However, then the wall by the stairs would be the only practical spot for a TV.
This could be a bit inconvenient due to the door in that area.

Any ideas?
What do you think?

Thanks & best regards
11ant31 May 2018 16:53
espressionist schrieb:
What we don’t like here is that an L-shaped sofa, as drawn, has its back in the middle of the room, which would visually shrink the space.
It would be better if the sofa were placed in the top right corner. However, then the wall next to the stairs would be the only reasonable spot for a TV.

When an equation doesn’t work out or produces unwanted solutions, I start looking for flawed assumptions. My two suspects are “you have to have a TV” and “the seating must be joined to form a fixed L shape.” Remove at least one unnecessary condition, and the degrees of freedom increase significantly.
https://www.instagram.com/11antgmxde/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/bauen-jetzt/
O
Otus11
31 May 2018 17:19
espressionist schrieb:

L-shaped sofa...
Any ideas?
What do you think?

Two 2.5-seat sofas placed parallel and facing each other, with a small table in between.
11ant31 May 2018 18:23
Otus11 schrieb:
Two parallel, opposite-facing 2.5-seater sofas,

Or arranged in any other way: once the "L" shape is cut at the corner, everything is possible (including 90° again, but no longer mandatory).
https://www.instagram.com/11antgmxde/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/bauen-jetzt/
sven.conzi3 Jun 2018 09:47
espressionist schrieb:
Our architect is currently still on vacation, so it’s not yet clear whether the kitchen and living area can be swapped.
That’s why we are also considering the current plan in parallel.


What we don’t like so much here is that an L-shaped sofa, as drawn, would have its back in the middle of the room, which would visually reduce the space.
It would be better if the sofa was placed in the upper right corner of the plan. However, then the wall next to the stairs would be the only sensible place for a TV.
With the door there, that could be somewhat inconvenient.

Any ideas?
What do you think?

Thanks & regards
We had the same issue (sofa in the middle of the room). We found a solution at friends’ place: a small partition wall in the middle (170cm (67 inches) wide), with the TV mounted on one side. The sofa is positioned 4m (13 feet) away from the wall. On either side of the partition wall, there is a passageway of 150cm (59 inches) and 200cm (79 inches). On the other side of the partition wall is the dining area. Since we had seen this beforehand and designed our space somewhat more generously, we like it a lot.