ᐅ Constructive Feedback on the Floor Plan Welcome

Created on: 9 Nov 2016 12:16
K
komet
K
komet
9 Nov 2016 12:16
Hello,
our house building plans are gradually becoming more concrete, and I have been moving walls around in the Sweet Home program for weeks. Now we have a first draft that we are quite satisfied with (probably the 3000th version), and I would appreciate your feedback...

We plan to build a two-story urban villa with a hip roof in a §34 designated area.
Size approximately 11.30 x 10.60 m (37.1 x 34.8 ft), living area about 200 sqm (2,153 sq ft)
No basement
West-East orientation
4 persons

Offices: 2 needed, one for family use, one for a home office
Overnight guests per year: 20
Open architecture
Modern construction method
Open kitchen with an island – still undecided
Number of permanent dining seats: 4, expandable to 12
Fireplace – yes
Music/stereo wall – no
Balcony, roof terrace – no
Garage, carport – yes

House design
Planner: DIY
Preferred heating system: still unclear, probably underfloor heating with a heat pump (air source)
It would be great to have a pantry accessible from the kitchen, but it seems too small at the moment, right?
Requested: wheelchair-accessible bathroom on the ground floor

We are still open regarding the staircase design. This draft shows a two-angle staircase, but maybe someone has a better idea.

Do you notice anything that might not work well? Looking forward to further suggestions...
RobsonMKK9 Nov 2016 12:19
Please upload as a JPG and not as a PDF.
K
komet
9 Nov 2016 12:34
Not so easy, but: ta-da... the ground floor itself looks kind of cramped. It should be fairly square... if anyone knows how to directly create a JPEG in Sweet Home 3D, I’d appreciate any tips...

Images deleted because they were distorted... see below 🙂
Y
ypg
9 Nov 2016 12:51




Screenshots 😉

Regards
L
Lanini
9 Nov 2016 12:53
I just took a quick look. Some measurements would be helpful. Also, more information is missing: What about the neighboring buildings? Do you have a site plan?

What I noticed:

Ground floor:
- Guest toilet is very long and narrow; how wide is the room? It doesn’t look accessible!
- What is the distance between the sofa and the TV?
- The dining area seems quite cramped. Measurements?
- Is the right side of the kitchen supposed to have a counter under the stairs? Is an open staircase planned?

Upper floor:
- I don’t like the indentation in Children's Room 2 for the bathtub and the 45° wall.
- The bathroom for the children’s room seems very small again. Measurements?
- Bathtub in the children’s bathroom, only a shower in the master bathroom... a matter of taste… just reconsider, children won’t live in the house forever and then you’ll always have to use the children’s bathroom to bathe?
- As the only bathtub in the house, I find the placement of the tub quite unfortunate, half-hidden behind the wall.
- Overall, I find all the bathrooms in this house too small and cramped.
- The arrangement of bedroom, dressing room, and bathroom is inconvenient.
- The indentations in Children's Room 1 and the master bedroom really aren’t necessary; the library (which seems to be intended as an office?) can be arranged differently.
- What is the small square next to the stairs and the dressing room?

In general, I would say: I don’t like the design, especially the upper floor. I find the layout quite convoluted and not very spacious. The house is about 200 m² (2,150 sq ft). With a house of this size, you can get much more out of it.

This is just a brief impression, without going into the design in more detail. I’m sure other users will share their opinions as well.
Y
ypg
9 Nov 2016 12:55
Could you please explain the kitchen/stair area in more detail?
No visible wall… Structural support?
Sitting area under the stairs? Sink located under the stairs?

Site plan? Plot? Access?

Dimensions?

Are you satisfied with the result?

Best regards