ᐅ Walk-in shower with linear drain or shower tray?

Created on: 6 Dec 2014 06:33
X
Xinette
Xinette6 Dec 2014 06:33
Hello everyone,

Your experiences are needed here as well.
Have you installed walk-in showers with linear drains or shower trays?
What has been your experience? What has proven to be reliable?
Best regards, Xinette
M
Manu1976
6 Dec 2014 09:34
We are getting a floor-level tiled shower with a wall drain. However, I don't have any experience with this yet.
One006 Dec 2014 11:05
We tiled the upper floor with floor-to-ceiling tiles and installed a nearly flush shower tray on the ground floor. However, we haven’t been able to use it yet because the shower enclosure has not been installed. I can no longer understand why we didn’t tile downstairs as well, since tiles look better in my opinion and are not more expensive. A tray is probably a bit easier to clean than tiles. I prefer tiles because they create a more continuous and therefore more spacious appearance compared to a tray.

The drain on the upper floor is located at the back wall and tiled in, working perfectly (why wouldn’t it?). The tray has a round drain in the corner.
A
Alex90
6 Dec 2014 20:52
In my personal opinion, a shower tray is a better long-term solution. Several bathroom suppliers have confirmed this to me as well. The reason is that with a tiled shower floor, you need to install a kind of "drain strip" or place the drain somewhere. After a few years (since the materials expand and contract), the silicone sealant might crack, allowing water to leak in unwanted areas. With a shower tray, this problem is less likely because the tray has a built-in slope. At least, that’s how it was explained to me.
I hope I described it correctly.
M
Manu1976
6 Dec 2014 22:21
And our plumbing expert dismissed that as nonsense (or rather as a sales argument FOR people who want to sell shower trays), since even a shower tray has silicone seals that can crack and where water can run under the shower base.
S
Saruss
6 Dec 2014 22:58
When we were installing our tiled shower, I noticed that beneath the drain cover there is a very large "dish"-shaped funnel, which is much bigger than the visible drain opening. This funnel extends under the adjacent tiles. I don’t see where a silicone seal would ensure watertightness here, so there is a potential risk that it could be higher than with shower trays. A kind of drip edge at the bottom also prevents water from running underneath. The rest of the plumbing is pretty much the same.