Hello dear forum,
Our ideas are slowly becoming more concrete, and we have found a floor plan that we quite like and that fits our requirements. We would love to hear your opinions and suggestions for improvement.
Development Plan/Restrictions
Plot size 518 sqm (5574 sq ft)
Slope Yes, about 2 m (6.5 ft) within the building zone, total about 3.5 m (11.5 ft), rising from the street
Floor area ratio 0.3
Plot ratio 0.6
Building zone, building line, and boundary approximately 13.5 x 12 m (44 x 39 ft)
Edge development As a new development area, everyone has the same specifications
Number of parking spaces 2
Number of floors 1.5 plus a basement, which is allowed and intended to be a full floor
Roof type gable roof, shed roof
Style open construction method
Orientation north-south
Maximum heights/limits 11 m (36 ft) ridge height
Homeowners’ Requirements
Style, roof type, building type single-family house with basement and gable roof
Basement, floors basement for living space plus 1.5 floors
Number of people, age currently a couple in their mid-30s plus a one-year-old child, more children planned
Space requirements
Ground floor: open plan living area, pantry/storage room, guest WC, 1 children’s room
Upper floor: 2 children’s rooms, family bathroom with bathtub, master bedroom with walk-in closet and shower bath
Basement: 2 offices, small shower bath, technical room/storage
Office: home office
Guest sleeping per year: rarely, so the office might occasionally be used as guest room
Open or closed architecture: open architecture
Open kitchen, kitchen island: open kitchen with island
Number of dining seats: at least 6
Fireplace: yes
Music/stereo wall: no
Balcony, roof terrace: standard terrace
Garage, carport: garage, but planned for later; possibly a carport
Utility garden, greenhouse: utility and play garden
Additional wishes/particulars: the main entrance will be moved to the basement, where the two offices are also planned. We want a high knee wall, which is why we plan a bay window to better utilize the 75% rule.
We are also still considering whether to place the main entrance on the left side of the house to make better use of space in the basement.
Furthermore, if possible, the terrace should be located above the garage on the right side of the house, as this side receives the most sun.
House Design
Who designed it: planner from a construction company plus do-it-yourself
What do you particularly like? the open and bright staircase, the living and dining area because everything is very bright
What do you dislike? Why? the solution with the parents’ area on the upper floor — hard to imagine and possibly too small
Price estimate according to architect/planner: 375,000
Personal price limit for the house, including equipment: 400,000
Preferred heating technology: air-to-water heat pump
If you have to give up something, which details/ extensions
-can you do without: fireplace
-can you not give up: parents’ area with walk-in and bathroom
Why did the design turn out as it is now? For example:
Standard design by the planner?
Which wishes were implemented by the architect? the plan is mainly the result of the spatial concept
What do you think makes it particularly good or bad? good question, it’s nothing exceptional, rather practical
What is the most important/fundamental question about the floor plan summarized in 130 characters?
What advantages or disadvantages do you see in the floor plan and design, especially regarding our large spatial concept?



Our ideas are slowly becoming more concrete, and we have found a floor plan that we quite like and that fits our requirements. We would love to hear your opinions and suggestions for improvement.
Development Plan/Restrictions
Plot size 518 sqm (5574 sq ft)
Slope Yes, about 2 m (6.5 ft) within the building zone, total about 3.5 m (11.5 ft), rising from the street
Floor area ratio 0.3
Plot ratio 0.6
Building zone, building line, and boundary approximately 13.5 x 12 m (44 x 39 ft)
Edge development As a new development area, everyone has the same specifications
Number of parking spaces 2
Number of floors 1.5 plus a basement, which is allowed and intended to be a full floor
Roof type gable roof, shed roof
Style open construction method
Orientation north-south
Maximum heights/limits 11 m (36 ft) ridge height
Homeowners’ Requirements
Style, roof type, building type single-family house with basement and gable roof
Basement, floors basement for living space plus 1.5 floors
Number of people, age currently a couple in their mid-30s plus a one-year-old child, more children planned
Space requirements
Ground floor: open plan living area, pantry/storage room, guest WC, 1 children’s room
Upper floor: 2 children’s rooms, family bathroom with bathtub, master bedroom with walk-in closet and shower bath
Basement: 2 offices, small shower bath, technical room/storage
Office: home office
Guest sleeping per year: rarely, so the office might occasionally be used as guest room
Open or closed architecture: open architecture
Open kitchen, kitchen island: open kitchen with island
Number of dining seats: at least 6
Fireplace: yes
Music/stereo wall: no
Balcony, roof terrace: standard terrace
Garage, carport: garage, but planned for later; possibly a carport
Utility garden, greenhouse: utility and play garden
Additional wishes/particulars: the main entrance will be moved to the basement, where the two offices are also planned. We want a high knee wall, which is why we plan a bay window to better utilize the 75% rule.
We are also still considering whether to place the main entrance on the left side of the house to make better use of space in the basement.
Furthermore, if possible, the terrace should be located above the garage on the right side of the house, as this side receives the most sun.
House Design
Who designed it: planner from a construction company plus do-it-yourself
What do you particularly like? the open and bright staircase, the living and dining area because everything is very bright
What do you dislike? Why? the solution with the parents’ area on the upper floor — hard to imagine and possibly too small
Price estimate according to architect/planner: 375,000
Personal price limit for the house, including equipment: 400,000
Preferred heating technology: air-to-water heat pump
If you have to give up something, which details/ extensions
-can you do without: fireplace
-can you not give up: parents’ area with walk-in and bathroom
Why did the design turn out as it is now? For example:
Standard design by the planner?
Which wishes were implemented by the architect? the plan is mainly the result of the spatial concept
What do you think makes it particularly good or bad? good question, it’s nothing exceptional, rather practical
What is the most important/fundamental question about the floor plan summarized in 130 characters?
What advantages or disadvantages do you see in the floor plan and design, especially regarding our large spatial concept?
Thirteen schrieb:
Yes, we need the basement rooms.
We have also considered relocating other rooms and the basement level. However, we find it difficult to imagine placing bedrooms in the basement. We have already discussed elsewhere that there are challenges with children’s rooms there. Since the slope rises from the street side, and the garden is accessible from the ground floor, we want the main living area on the ground floor as well. Why do you find it hard to imagine sleeping in the basement? For example, if the front door is also located in the basement and it is open on three sides, it surely wouldn’t feel like a typical "basement atmosphere." I think bedrooms directly against the slope would be more comfortable—because they’re cooler—than in the attic. My idea was actually the opposite of the other suggestion (children later moving to the basement): initially, the children would share a bedroom in the basement while the upper floor might only have an office and a shower room. Later, the arrangement would switch so the children have their own rooms upstairs.
If that doesn’t appeal to you, I would at least move the pantry to the basement.
I wouldn’t reserve basement space for a vague “maybe later” but would use it fully from the start. I still can’t imagine that you will be able to manage the budget.
How to find general contractors? Search this forum for your state or neighboring counties. Maybe there is already a report about experiences. Visit newly developed areas with hillside plots and ask about their experiences. Use Google Maps (search terms: residential construction, masonry house, house building, architect), regional building fairs.
P
pagoni20209 Jul 2020 09:58@Thirteen You’ve received some really great suggestions from @Ideensucher and @Ysop***, ideas that could truly solve your situation in a new way. You should let go of your previously fixed requirements. Even though your situation might be quite different, I had almost the same one myself. It’s not about sleeping in the basement, but rather at the front on the ground floor, which is probably pleasantly cool; we had that and decided to create a spacious bedroom instead. Free yourself from the idea of a dark, cold, musty basement and design it as living space, because that’s what it actually is. You just need to properly equip it with windows, sufficient ceiling height, and so on—basically, make it NOT feel like a basement. The exposed part will probably not be concrete but built with regular masonry anyway. If you include the basement in your plans as living space, you’ll gain completely new and attractive options.
People usually think (we did too) only about the time when the kids are happily running around and want a cozy, comfortable home. But as Bob Dylan sings, “The times are a-changin’”… and quite fast. You’ll feel great when you can allow your oldest child to have their own space somewhere. I totally agree with [USER=52074]@Ideensucher when he says that children might even sleep better in the same room for a certain time, or even should. You might encounter some head shaking with such thoughts in your environment (many know-it-alls); well, we did. Time will tell, and I’m confident that these suggestions will pay off for you, while others often end up living in unsuitable floor plans.
Be brave and go for it if that feels right for you personally!
People usually think (we did too) only about the time when the kids are happily running around and want a cozy, comfortable home. But as Bob Dylan sings, “The times are a-changin’”… and quite fast. You’ll feel great when you can allow your oldest child to have their own space somewhere. I totally agree with [USER=52074]@Ideensucher when he says that children might even sleep better in the same room for a certain time, or even should. You might encounter some head shaking with such thoughts in your environment (many know-it-alls); well, we did. Time will tell, and I’m confident that these suggestions will pay off for you, while others often end up living in unsuitable floor plans.
Be brave and go for it if that feels right for you personally!
You are absolutely right! I’m very grateful for your ideas!
I’m actually considering removing the second bathroom from the upper floor, since you really only need it once the kids are older and tend to occupy the bathroom for a long time.
We generally want to keep the option open to move to the basement when we’re older or create a separate living area there for older children or possibly even a tenant.
I’m going back and forth, trying to decide which solution would be better.
- Three bedrooms in the basement with a shower bathroom, then on the upper floor just one large bathroom and a master bedroom with walk-in closet plus two office rooms, so the kids would eventually move to the basement. (Of course, with a shower bathroom there as well.)
- Master bedroom with walk-in closet and shower bathroom in the basement, possibly plus two other rooms, and then the upper floor fully developed for the children, meaning three children’s bedrooms plus a bathroom.
I’m actually considering removing the second bathroom from the upper floor, since you really only need it once the kids are older and tend to occupy the bathroom for a long time.
We generally want to keep the option open to move to the basement when we’re older or create a separate living area there for older children or possibly even a tenant.
I’m going back and forth, trying to decide which solution would be better.
- Three bedrooms in the basement with a shower bathroom, then on the upper floor just one large bathroom and a master bedroom with walk-in closet plus two office rooms, so the kids would eventually move to the basement. (Of course, with a shower bathroom there as well.)
- Master bedroom with walk-in closet and shower bathroom in the basement, possibly plus two other rooms, and then the upper floor fully developed for the children, meaning three children’s bedrooms plus a bathroom.
I
Ideensucher9 Jul 2020 11:11Thirteen schrieb:
We generally want to keep the option open to move to the basement when we’re older or to create a separate living area there for grown children or possibly even a tenant.
I’m currently weighing up which would be the better solution. If I were to have a tenant in the house, I would prefer them to live below me. That way, you don’t have anyone stomping on the ceiling.
Since you don’t have children yet, that won’t be for at least another 20 years – planning that far ahead is quite ambitious.
Five years ago, I bought a condominium, and now it’s too small for us because our situation has changed.
pagoni2020 schrieb:
@11ant describes it absolutely correctly; I would have the basement built, so in your case, only solid construction would be an option for me.Invalid causal connection!pagoni2020 schrieb:
For me, the part in the ground was poured in concrete by the construction company, and the rest was built with masonry at the front.That is probably the most sensible combination.Thirteen schrieb:
I roughly made a basement floor plan,... which, however, is methodologically nonsense because you are continuing based on an outdated building volume.Moreover, the new development area borders one that is already a whole generation old. Their construction companies from back then will probably still exist for the most part.
https://www.instagram.com/11antgmxde/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/bauen-jetzt/
P
pagoni20209 Jul 2020 11:25Thirteen schrieb:
We generally want to keep the option open to move into the basement later in life or create a separate living area there for older children or possibly even a tenant.Absolutely, very good option…..with a separate exit to the outside, so it’s truly independent. Who knows who or why you might rent it out to someday… From my own experience, I can say that this solution ultimately increased the resale value significantly, mainly because of the separate sale potential. Just keep in mind the distribution of water, heating, etc., from the start, so it can be separated if needed. That doesn’t cost much more besides some thoughtful planning.Thirteen schrieb:
I’m actually considering removing the second bathroom from the upper floor, because you really only need it when the kids are older and monopolize the bathroom for a long time.Exactly;… and then it’s better for it to be on a different floor anyway. Much more comfortable for the overall living situation and frees up much-needed space upstairs. A fatherly friend used to say: “What happens often, happens often, and what is rare, stays rare.” I try to keep that in mind during house planning, because enthusiasm often leads to ideas that don’t match everyday life very well.Option A:
Sounds good, and you could always decide situationally whether the room is used as an office or a bedroom. Children are at different ages and have different needs. Just by furnishing, you can easily switch uses, because there’s a comfortable living environment everywhere and a bathroom nearby.
Option B:
Basically, it’s no different rooms, just different uses, which you can change again as you like, even shortly before or after moving in. In general, I could imagine the kids would prefer to be upstairs. In the basement, you would have an outside exit, which the kids probably wouldn’t need to use. The idea of a basement bedroom, really large and nice, divided with lightweight walls for possible future changes, sounds good. A potential tenant (could also be grandparents or family members, depending on the situation) should obviously only be downstairs, otherwise it won’t work. This is also just a fallback plan. Option B would cover all that, and then you only need the right floor plan with somewhat flexible walls, which I would prefer anyway. Maybe you should have the floor plan redesigned with these new ideas in mind, rather than tweaking the existing one floor by floor from now on. Have fun……
Similar topics