ᐅ New construction, 166 sqm / 1.5 stories / floor plan for a family of five

Created on: 28 Aug 2020 11:43
N
netuser
Good day and hello dear forum community!

As a family of five, we have planned to build a house ourselves—or rather have it built—by summer/autumn 2021.

We already purchased a plot of land in 2019, the construction contract with Gussek Haus is signed, and the financing is largely arranged. So now we are about to enter the critical planning phase with the architect, where all details will be thoroughly reviewed, adjusted back and forth, and the building permit (planning permission) application will be prepared.

Since the attached drawings represent only a "rough draft" and can and should still be adjusted, I would greatly appreciate your assessments, advice, or criticism. Especially the latter, as long as it remains constructive, is very welcome.

About our situation, requirements, and wishes:
(Thanks to ypg for the template )

Development Plan / Restrictions




















































Plot size 550 sqm (5920 sq ft)
Slope no
Site coverage ratio 0.4
Floor area ratio 166 sqm (1786 sq ft)
Building envelope, building line and boundary 14 m (46 ft), see attachment
Number of parking spaces /
Number of stories 1.5
Roof style 40° - 45° (gable roof)
Maximum height/limits 4.5 m eave height (14.8 ft)


Owners’ Requirements




















































Basement, floors no basement; 1.5 floors
Number of occupants, ages 2 adults, 3 children (15, 9, 4)
Space needed on ground floor and upper floor see floor plan
Office: family use or home office? part-time home office; otherwise a multifunctional room for computer work, ironing, etc.
Overnight guests per year 20-30
Number of dining seats 5 daily; at least 12 otherwise
Garage, carport 1 garage (next to the entrance on the north side), later 1 carport (on the south side)


House Design










































Who designed the plan? Gussek Haus; a model house served as a base with our own modifications
What do you particularly like? Why? "Square, practical, good" for everyday family life without unnecessary frills
What do you not like? Why? At first we saw the east orientation as unfavorable, but now we also see some advantages.

The ground floor WC does not yet have a suitable solution for the shower.

The bathroom on the upper floor is not optimal yet and feels a bit too small.
Preferred heating system: Air-to-water heat pump + controlled mechanical ventilation



If you have to give up something, which details/fixtures












You can live without: good question
You cannot live without: Bedroom/guest room + shower on the ground floor



Why is the design as it is now?

We want to make the best possible use of the available space and design it to be practical.

The plot drawing is oriented to true north, the floor plans are not. The top is south, the bottom is north. This means the garage, entrance, and utility room are deliberately placed on the north side. The kitchen and dining/living room should have access to the garden on the east side. Possibly, we would like to design the terrace wrapping around the corner to the east/south.

We do not want or cannot give up the number of rooms at the moment. However, if it makes sense to shift walls here and there or change rooms, we welcome suggestions.

The utility room is a bit small, but should be acceptable since the water tank marked in red does not fit in after all.

What is your most important/basic question about the floor plan, summarized in 130 characters?

Valuable advice is welcome! Many thanks in advance!

Site plan of a building plot with parcels, boundary lines, and building markings


2D floor plan of a single-family house with kitchen, living room, bedroom, and hallway


Detailed floor plan of an upper floor with children's rooms, study rooms, and bath
E
evelinoz
28 Aug 2020 16:08
It doesn’t really matter how the table is positioned; these sliding door partitions require quite a bit of space in a kitchen because you need to allow clearance around the standing wall sections. The necessary distance to an island (if desired) is often not available.

Also, I can’t imagine this door being closed often with five people in the house.

That’s true, hinged doors are easier to operate than sliding doors.

Yes, those very popular oversized windows, especially when facing south, can be a nightmare in summer. You often end up sitting in semi-darkness. Big windows are great, but only in the right place. Very few have a view that actually benefits from such large window areas. Someone once wrote that everything else you see is just the son’s tractor, the swing, the sandbox, and garden furniture.
C
Curly
28 Aug 2020 16:55
The shower bathroom on the ground floor would be too small for the parents. The bathroom on the upper floor is used by the children, so there is no space left for the parents there.

Best regards
Sabine
Y
ypg
28 Aug 2020 23:55
netuser schrieb:

Thanks to ypg for the template )
Thank you for your attention
Y
ypg
29 Aug 2020 12:08
netuser schrieb:

So, the garage, entrance, and utility room are deliberately located on the north side. The kitchen and dining/living area should have access to the garden on the east side.

Your mentioned bedroom has the best location on the site. I would place the main living area, whether open or closed, facing southwest, the bedroom to the east, and the utility room to the northeast. Or something similar. Advantage: the living area would get natural light in the afternoon during the darker months. Basically, just invert the house orientation.
netuser schrieb:

Actually, I forgot to mention that I am only interested in evaluating the floor plans, not the proposed furnishings.

The actual furnishings are important for assessment: here you can see that the sliding door might cause problems when guests visit, the wardrobe is just a coat hook after all, and the bathroom on the ground floor is insufficient.
netuser schrieb:

We are still unsure about the following points:

1. Whether to keep the large kitchen window (door) or replace it with a narrower one?
2. Whether to keep the kitchen open or semi-open with sliding doors as in the drawing.

Have you considered separating the living room?
And regarding kitchen furnishings: island or no island? As drawn or differently?
netuser schrieb:

3. The staircase is currently planned to be closed, to create a small storage room/pantry underneath.
Here the cost-benefit ratio matters. Is the probably quite small additional space worth the 2,000 euros extra?

Do it! Where will you put your shoes and jackets? Without a wall or closet under the stairs, hardly feasible.
netuser schrieb:

The wardrobe only provides space for coat hooks and shoe storage. That’s why it is around the corner, to keep all that clutter out of direct sight from the entrance area.

Hmm... it’s not fully “out of sight” right now, since the bedroom is pretty much directly opposite.
As I said before, I would arrange the living room, dining area, and kitchen more toward the southwest rather than southeast. The terrace I see wrapping around the corner, but more on the south side.
You will hardly be happy with the guest bathroom or the parents’ bath: it will be quite tight and uncomfortable. You’ll probably use the staircase and the upstairs bathroom more often anyway.
If it were me, I’d reconsider the room layout once more. Conservatively, I see the bedroom better located on the sleeping floor rather than as a hobby or office room. The children will have to keep their rooms tidy anyway, and I see the home office better separated from the children’s rooms.
In any case, I would probably create a combined kitchen/living area or include the living room with it. Then separate the hobby room from the main living area and find a way to incorporate or use it. That makes more sense to me than having the bedroom with just an emergency shower on the ground floor.
11ant29 Aug 2020 16:14
ypg schrieb:

Do it! Where do you keep your shoes and coats? Without a wall or cupboard under the stairs, it's hardly feasible.

Yes, in this case the wardrobe is more conveniently located here than a pantry.
https://www.instagram.com/11antgmxde/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/bauen-jetzt/
H
hampshire
29 Aug 2020 16:39
The design is well-structured, successful, and compact. In my opinion, evaluating it without furnishing does not make much sense. The house is a shell for your life. Therefore, pathways and space for everyone definitely matter. Especially with compact room dimensions, it is crucial how furniture, space, lighting, and movement fit together.
netuser schrieb:

1. Whether to keep the large kitchen window (door) or replace it with a narrower one!?
If you use this door frequently and, for example, have an herb garden in front of it or can imagine an unofficial “children’s play entrance”: keep it wide.
netuser schrieb:

2. Whether the kitchen remains open or semi-open as shown in the drawing with sliding doors.
We prefer it open. But that may not apply to you. The advantage I see is a more spacious feeling in the living area.
netuser schrieb:

3. The staircase is currently planned as closed to create a small storage room/pantry underneath.
Here, the cost-benefit ratio matters. Is the probably quite small space gain worth the 2,000 euros extra charge!?
It is worth it. Less work (cleaning under an open staircase is annoying) and a dust-free utility space. 2,000 euros is reasonable for a custom built-in unit – you can spend money much worse.