ᐅ House with or without a basement

Created on: 17 Aug 2015 10:11
M
MrDuncan
We are currently considering whether to build our house with or without a basement. Normally, we would prefer a basement, but the groundwater level is very high in our area, which is why our neighbors were also unable to have one. What alternatives would you suggest, and how do you estimate the costs? I have looked into a waterproof basement shell, but the construction company advised against it, saying it would be too expensive and not cost-effective.
S
Skaddler
26 Aug 2015 22:33
The office is located on the upper floor. My wife would be furious if I suggested she work her 32 hours per week in the basement :-D
M
Manu1976
26 Aug 2015 22:46
My husband also complained about his office in the basement. Working from home wasn’t really possible there, or only at the living room table, because he couldn’t get any mobile phone reception in the basement – despite a large window. But the thick concrete walls (watertight concrete shell) still made it impossible.
The guest room eventually turned into a junk room. It’s big, so everything went in there at first – thinking it could be tidied up later. Now the office is on the ground floor, and the guest room was replaced by a playroom in the attic.
M
Müllerin
26 Aug 2015 22:46
Hmm, for a sloped site: a basement, of course. It will also have good natural light. But for a regular basement, getting sufficient daylight in is only possible if you have a very large plot that allows you to excavate a slope around the house in front of the windows?
M
Manu1976
26 Aug 2015 22:51
That's true. Although we had a somewhat raised basement, we still had a light well around 2 windows measuring about 3x2 meters (10x7 feet), which took up quite a bit of space in the small garden.
Bautraum201527 Aug 2015 08:53
If you have an extra-large lot like we do, light wells at the basement windows are not a problem at all. Our guest room is frequently used by friends, almost every week, so the argument about clutter doesn’t apply to us. Additionally, we have a separate room where we store cabinets with Christmas items, Easter decorations, gift materials, and even a corner used as a wine cellar... and even this room is tidy and well organized. So, if you tend to be messy and disorganized, it might actually be better to skip the basement :p
Weimy27 Aug 2015 11:30
passivhaus schrieb:
We also won’t have a basement. If I had the money, I would rather invest it in a nice conservatory or sunroom, as you get more use out of it.

Hello,

that’s exactly what we did... we will have a conservatory in the future. By the way, it’s not a 1990s-style or “old-fashioned” one, but modern, open, and bright! It will be integrated into our living room—so no separate patio door—and will extend from the roof...

Our decision against a basement is not based on financial reasons. We don’t need such a large basement, and I’m also tired of constantly having to go downstairs. I’m really looking forward to a basement-free time.