ᐅ Critique of the Floor Plan Design for a Farmhouse

Created on: 24 Oct 2015 16:22
G
grinchmaster
Hello to the forum community!
I have been following this forum diligently for over a year now (since I started looking into house construction), and I have already gained a lot of valuable information here.
Now our house building plans have matured enough that I would like to present them to you.
The basic planning is in place. However, we are currently experiencing some project blindness, which is causing the planning to stall a bit. This is where I need your feedback and ideas!

We want to extend the parents-in-law’s house. For planning reasons, the new building should be designed as an extension of the existing house, creating a multi-generation home. If this is not approved by the building authority (building permit / planning permission), we will split the plot at the existing garage and register easements.
The idea is to build a sleeping house using solid construction, adjoining a kind of living barn in timber frame construction. We want to separate the areas for children/parents/living, have an inner courtyard at the back of the house, and stylistically create a small farmyard-like complex to blend in with the surroundings 🙂

Development plan/restrictions: none
Plot size: approx. 900 sqm (total approx. 2300 sqm)
Slope: no
Building zone, building line, and boundary: NE: street; SE: existing house with garage; SW: meadow; NW: field path
Number of parking spaces: 2
Number of stories: 2 / 1
Roof type: gable roof / shed roof
Style: farmhouse – sleeping house with living barn
Orientation: southwest

Client requirements
Style, roof type, building type: farmhouse, gable roof / shed roof
Basement, stories: no basement, 2 / 1 (approx. 210 sqm + attic)
Number of people, ages: 2 + 2 children + 1 planned
Office: family use and home office (very small space requirement)
Occasional overnight guests per year: about 10 times for 4 people
Open or closed architecture: sleeping area closed; living area open and bright
Open kitchen, kitchen island: yes, possible
Seating places at dining table: 6–8
Fireplace: yes
Carport: yes

House design
Who designed it: architect
What is liked: arrangement of living, parents, children areas.
What is disliked?
- Carport darkens the bathroom
- Entrance to the parents’ bathroom
- Layout of living barn: Where to place the fireplace? How to design the kitchen? Kitchen and dining room should form a unit. Living room separated (by fireplace, timber frame wall?)
Cost estimate according to architect/planner: 370,000 (own estimate: minimum 400,000 – without exterior landscaping)
Preferred heating technology: ground source heat pump / gas???
If you have to cut back, on which details/features
- can be omitted: could be smaller as well.
- cannot be omitted: large windows in the living area

Now I look forward to your opinions and ideas!

(In the floor plans, north is at the bottom right)
G
grinchmaster
29 Oct 2015 22:23
Ah, now I understand what you mean. I will include it in the further planning.
N
nightdancer
30 Oct 2015 09:26
450k during the planning stage? Ambitious. I would have estimated an all-in cost of 500k+ instead.
G
grinchmaster
3 Nov 2015 22:07
I currently have a concern.

The following points bother me about the master bathroom:
- From the bedroom, you have to walk an "S-curve" to reach the bathroom;
- The door swings against the bathtub;
- There is a lot of unused circulation space.
I could accept some of these issues individually, but not all together.

How could the bathroom layout be optimized?

Grundriss eines Hauses mit Schlafraum, Bad, Ankleide und Flur
Y
ypg
3 Nov 2015 23:10
You could place the bathroom door opposite the other door, but then you would have very little space for a large washbasin. You could rotate the bathtub or replace the bathtub with a smaller washbasin. However, I think it works quite well as it is. The door does not hit the bathtub. You just have very limited space because of the many windows...
K
kbt09
4 Nov 2015 06:05
You mentioned this before, and I have also considered making changes. However, nothing practical came of it.

And I don’t think the position of the bathroom door is bad. When you come out, you are right in the middle of your cabinets 😉
G
grinchmaster
4 Nov 2015 22:12
Result of my considerations:
- Door opposite the bedroom door on the wall.
- Washbasin on the wall where the bathtub/shower are.
- Shower in the WC niche.
- Bathtub centered under the windows.
- WC to the left of the bathtub, at the bottom of the plan in the left corner.
The windows would need to be adjusted accordingly (possibly a partition wall to the bathtub).
What do you think?