ᐅ Basement versus Increased Living Space on the Ground Floor

Created on: 19 Apr 2022 20:36
H
HalloClarissa
Dear all,

We are planning to build a bungalow with 3 rooms and about 85 sqm (915 sq ft) of living space. Since the plot is on a slope, we need to build with a partial basement.

Which option would likely be more cost-effective:

1. Living area on the ground floor (including a guest room) of 85 sqm (915 sq ft) and a 50 sqm (538 sq ft) basement used mainly as a utility cellar with a technical room (then we would only need one bathroom).

2. Ground floor only 75 sqm (808 sq ft), guest room in the partially finished 50 sqm (538 sq ft) basement as living space (which would require a second bathroom but could be fitted out later by ourselves).

As soon as the basement is meant to have living space, the access routes must be heated and insulated. Also, an internal staircase is necessary. A purely utility basement could possibly be accessed only from outside without an internal staircase, saving space.

Theoretically, a room on the ground floor requires about 12 sqm (129 sq ft). If this room is located in the basement, additional space for stairs on both floors and another hallway is needed, approximately 24 sqm (258 sq ft).

Am I thinking about this correctly?

Has anyone calculated a similar case before?

Leeres Baugrundstück mit gelbem, gebogenen Schutzrohr am Boden; Hintergrund Häuserzeile.
askforafriend20 Apr 2022 17:21
I’m definitely not going to link my project here haha 🙂
Y
ypg
20 Apr 2022 17:21
askforafriend schrieb:

I am currently building a house on a slope with a basement intended for living space, including an external staircase, retaining walls, and embankments.

However, a basement used as living space is not really desired, but rather a last resort, so alternatives are now being sought.
gutentag20 Apr 2022 17:24
askforafriend schrieb:

I’m not going to link my project here haha 🙂
That was meant to be just an internal link. I thought the project had already been presented here. You’re welcome to send me the designs via PM. I am very interested in sloped lot sites and their house planning. Confidentiality regarding your project is guaranteed.
Y
ypg
20 Apr 2022 17:44
gutentag schrieb:

@HalloClarissa, could you please accurately mark the plot on the development plan? With such an extreme slope, precise planning is essential.

To consider how you can arrive at an affordable solution, it’s important to know what the development plan specifies and what the site plan says about the blue line or property boundary. It looks to me as if there is only a building envelope?
However, you still need to find out if there are any restrictions.
11ant20 Apr 2022 18:13
ypg schrieb:

It looks to me like it's just a building envelope?

Above the "WA," there are endpoints of lines that probably originate from usage templates. For hillside construction plans, I would also be surprised if there were no specifications regarding the eaves heights on the uphill and downhill sides, or similar details.
https://www.instagram.com/11antgmxde/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/bauen-jetzt/
HalloClarissa20 Apr 2022 18:25
gutentag schrieb:

@HalloClarissa could you please accurately mark the plot on the zoning plan? With such a steep slope, precise planning is essential. Or is there already no budget left for a ruler?

Alternatively, a site plan where the cutouts are positioned to have a reference point that can be found on the zoning plan would also work.

We don’t know the project yet, only you do.
I am a bit puzzled by the comment “or is there already no budget left for a ruler”—what is that supposed to mean? If you are concerned about my financing: thank you, but that’s not necessary; I no longer need to take out a loan.
Regarding the plot marked by finger… unfortunately, my phone doesn’t have more advanced features.

I don’t have more detailed documents yet because the extended soil survey is still pending, and the building area has not yet been finally surveyed. Currently, I am planning based on the zoning plan and the drawing I already posted here.
However, this does not really relate to my actual question.