ᐅ Poor painting work or faulty plastering?

Created on: 22 Feb 2023 11:16
S
Sandra84
Hello everyone!
Something doesn’t seem right here, but I’m a complete beginner, and the painter is blaming the plasterer, and vice versa.
What do you think—is it poor plastering or poor painting?
White, empty corner of a room with painted walls, light spot on the wall, cardboard floor covering with a blue object.

Interior: white walls, window with black frame and blinds; green plant in the foreground

Bright stairwell with high walls, narrow window; view of a wintry outdoor scene.

Two cacti in a purple pot on the windowsill in front of a wall, winter landscape visible outside

Textured wall with a triple switch panel, glass door handle, and green plant.

Bright interior: beige wall, glass sliding door, and a floor lamp next to a houseplant.
S
Sandra84
2 Mar 2023 10:00
Tolentino schrieb:

Yes, it’s possible. At least any competent painter should still be able to manage that. Unless they know their paint is really bad and that it can’t (or won’t) be sanded off, and nothing else will stick to it.
But yeah, for just a thousand it won’t be done, even without bad paint.

Thanks, that already sounds quite promising.
S
Sandra84
2 Mar 2023 10:03
ypg schrieb:

I have some difficulty assessing the plaster because the photo quality is not the best. These are smartphone pictures, and the phone software can alter images quite a bit.
What I see here doesn’t really match our own Q2 plaster. Q2 is also fine-grained! This looks more like our exterior plaster texture, which is coarser.
Additionally, it seems the painter may have used too little paint.

As I said before: what you see in these photos might not accurately reflect reality.


Yes, unfortunately, the plaster often looks different in smartphone pictures. I took some close-up photos of the plaster. Maybe the texture will be clearer then. In some areas it’s very smooth, and in others quite grainy.
Grey painted wall with fine texture.

White wall surface with coarse, textured plaster pattern.

Light grey wall with small-scale, irregular plaster surface, no objects visible.

Grey painted plaster wall with irregular, grainy texture.
S
Sandra84
2 Mar 2023 10:07
LastCookie schrieb:

Exactly! What kind of plaster did the plasterer use? It looks like roughcast.

Besides that, I see the “mistake” here with the painter. Even as a “professional,” they have some responsibility to inform the layperson that you shouldn’t just paint over a surface like this.
But who knows what kind of “professional” was involved. The original poster can probably provide more details—if they want to.

A lime-cement plaster was used, and I also think it looks very rough.
If the painter had properly informed me, of course I would have had it skimmed and sanded.
X
xMisterDx
2 Mar 2023 19:57
Are there any pictures of the plaster before painting?