W
WILHELM386 Nov 2020 08:37Hello everyone,
I have been experiencing an issue for some time with the drawer handles on my Malm dressers from IKEA breaking very quickly. These are often the plastic handles attached with two screws. I am particularly interested in understanding why these handles are so prone to breaking, even though the furniture itself seems relatively sturdy. Could it be related to the choice of material for the handle, the installation, or possibly a design weakness? Are there any known weak points in this area that could explain why the handles break so easily? And what solutions or alternatives might you suggest to avoid this problem? I would appreciate any well-informed advice.
I have been experiencing an issue for some time with the drawer handles on my Malm dressers from IKEA breaking very quickly. These are often the plastic handles attached with two screws. I am particularly interested in understanding why these handles are so prone to breaking, even though the furniture itself seems relatively sturdy. Could it be related to the choice of material for the handle, the installation, or possibly a design weakness? Are there any known weak points in this area that could explain why the handles break so easily? And what solutions or alternatives might you suggest to avoid this problem? I would appreciate any well-informed advice.
The issue mainly lies in the combination of materials and the construction method of the Malm handles.
The handles are usually made of a brittle plastic that develops small microcracks over time due to mechanical stress. Under stronger loads, these quickly lead to visible breaks.
Installation conditions are often less than ideal, as the screws are positioned in very thin areas of the handle, creating stress points that are not sufficiently reinforced.
I recommend switching to sturdy metal handles when replacing them or, alternatively, choosing the metal versions of the Malm handles from IKEA.
The handles are usually made of a brittle plastic that develops small microcracks over time due to mechanical stress. Under stronger loads, these quickly lead to visible breaks.
WILHELM38 schrieb:
Is it due to the choice of handle material, the installation, or perhaps a design weakness?
Installation conditions are often less than ideal, as the screws are positioned in very thin areas of the handle, creating stress points that are not sufficiently reinforced.
I recommend switching to sturdy metal handles when replacing them or, alternatively, choosing the metal versions of the Malm handles from IKEA.
Hey WILHELM38, I’m unfortunately very familiar with that problem. 😕
That sums it up perfectly! Malm furniture is really practical, but the handles tend to break more often because they are basically the weak point in the design. If you also try to pull drawers fully loaded very hard, it creates a huge leverage effect that the plastic just doesn’t hold up to for long.
I eventually replaced my handles with metal ones – not only did it improve the look, but they also last much longer. :-)
vinli schrieb:
The handles are usually made of a brittle plastic that develops tiny microcracks over time due to mechanical stress
That sums it up perfectly! Malm furniture is really practical, but the handles tend to break more often because they are basically the weak point in the design. If you also try to pull drawers fully loaded very hard, it creates a huge leverage effect that the plastic just doesn’t hold up to for long.
I eventually replaced my handles with metal ones – not only did it improve the look, but they also last much longer. :-)
Interesting points about the material behavior mentioned here. However, I would like to add another perspective:
This is true, but one should also ask whether the design of the handles was sufficiently tested to cover typical load scenarios. It is possible that the breakages are not only due to the material but also a result of inadequate structural reinforcement against lever forces.
Additionally, I would be interested to know whether the breakages occur equally frequently across all models or if there are variants with significant differences. Such data could help identify manufacturing defects or quality variations.
Try asking how often and under what conditions the handles break for you – this can help narrow down the issue.
gasidney schrieb:
The handles of Malm are made of relatively thin plastic, which breaks quickly under excessive or improper load.
This is true, but one should also ask whether the design of the handles was sufficiently tested to cover typical load scenarios. It is possible that the breakages are not only due to the material but also a result of inadequate structural reinforcement against lever forces.
Additionally, I would be interested to know whether the breakages occur equally frequently across all models or if there are variants with significant differences. Such data could help identify manufacturing defects or quality variations.
Try asking how often and under what conditions the handles break for you – this can help narrow down the issue.
W
WILHELM388 Nov 2020 11:49Thank you all for your many helpful answers so far!
@Linavin, I think your suggestion regarding the type of load is very fitting. When I think about it, the handles seem to get damaged mainly when the drawer is fully loaded and I pull it relatively abruptly – there is surely a lot of leverage force acting on the handle in that situation.
One question I have is whether the screws are really seated perfectly or if they might be overtightened? I’ve sometimes had trouble with the screws because tightening them actually deformed the handle structure.
That sounds like a practical solution to me, although I had wanted to stick with the original parts for now. If I use metal handles, do you know if the mounting will stay compatible? Or would larger drill holes be necessary?
@Linavin, I think your suggestion regarding the type of load is very fitting. When I think about it, the handles seem to get damaged mainly when the drawer is fully loaded and I pull it relatively abruptly – there is surely a lot of leverage force acting on the handle in that situation.
One question I have is whether the screws are really seated perfectly or if they might be overtightened? I’ve sometimes had trouble with the screws because tightening them actually deformed the handle structure.
tutan schrieb:
I eventually replaced my handles with metal ones – not only did it improve the look, but they also last much longer.
That sounds like a practical solution to me, although I had wanted to stick with the original parts for now. If I use metal handles, do you know if the mounting will stay compatible? Or would larger drill holes be necessary?
Similar topics