ᐅ How is the maximum allowable living area calculated?

Created on: 11 Jan 2025 01:06
B
baulaie89
Hello everyone,

I am currently planning a semi-detached house on a sloped site and have run into a major problem that is causing me a lot of frustration. Maybe someone here can help me understand it better.

Here are the key details:
  • Plot size: 217 m² (2337 sq ft), floor area ratio: 0.45 → maximum buildable footprint of 97.65 m² (1051 sq ft).
  • No floor space index specified.
  • 1 full storey allowed, with a gable roof at 35° pitch (eaves height max. 4.50 m (14.8 ft), ridge height max. 9.00 m (29.5 ft)).
  • Currently planned living area: 131 m² (1410 sq ft) (ground floor and attic).
  • Balcony: 7.5 m² (81 sq ft); I wanted to make it a bit larger.

My architect strictly refuses to enlarge the balcony, saying that this would exceed the maximum allowable living area. However, he does not explain in detail how this limit on the maximum living area is calculated. There seems to be an absolute limit that, according to him, must not be exceeded. I understand that the ground floor footprint is clearly restricted by the floor area ratio (97.65 m² (1051 sq ft)). But how is the maximum possible living area in the attic calculated? The eaves height, ridge height, and roof pitch naturally limit the usable space—but what is the basis for determining this maximum area? I haven’t received any convincing explanations from my architect on this.

I am currently quite at a loss and would appreciate any help to better understand this or any advice on how to proceed. Thank you very much in advance!
Y
ypg
12 Jan 2025 10:46
hanghaus2023 schrieb:

Utility room in the open space. Going down to the basement every time is not very convenient.

Yes, last night the floor plans no longer displayed on my iPad when I wanted to check the ground floor because of the open space.
I completely agree with you. Or alternatively a walk-in closet, storage room, utility room.
Just having a gap above a sofa leading upwards can feel very uncomfortable.
H
hanghaus2023
12 Jan 2025 10:48
Maybe that would be considered living space and mess up the entire calculation?
Y
ypg
12 Jan 2025 10:53
hanghaus2023 schrieb:

Could it be that this refers to the living area and disrupts the entire calculation?

At least regarding the single-story aspect?! I consider the architect quite competent and believe they have calculated everything else correctly.
H
hanghaus2023
12 Jan 2025 11:05
One thing I noticed: how long is the roof of the carport? There are windows underneath, so hardly any light will reach the ground floor. I saw this in our residential area where someone used a patio roof for the carport. That might be an option as well, if a green roof is not required.
N
nordanney
12 Jan 2025 15:59
baulaie89 schrieb:

THANK YOU! Unfortunately, the laws do not clearly define which building a balcony belongs to, and that causes confusion.
They do. Additionally, here is a court ruling for you.

Excerpt from Federal Administrative Court ruling: Auxiliary structures are not part of the main building.
B
baulaie89
12 Jan 2025 21:56
hanghaus2023 schrieb:
What I noticed is, how long is the roof of the carport? There are windows underneath, so hardly any light will reach the ground floor. I saw this in my neighborhood where someone used a patio cover for the carport. That might be an option, if a green roof is not required.

I estimate about 7.5 meters (25 feet) based on the covered carport shown in the calculations. According to the building plan, this must also be covered with vegetation. Since the kitchen is open-plan, the light will likely come through the large living room windows.