ᐅ Why does adjusting the shelves in a Billy bookcase often cause problems?

Created on: 18 May 2021 08:13
G
Guylau
Hello everyone,

Lately, I have noticed that adjusting the shelves in IKEA Billy bookcases often causes problems. This is not just about simply moving the metal pins, but also concerns the stability and fit of the shelves after adjustment.

More specifically: Why does adjusting the shelves in Billy units frequently lead to issues such as unstable construction, shelves falling out or becoming misaligned, and sometimes even damage to the unit itself?

I am interested in whether the design of the drilled holes, the material quality, the assembly system, or other factors are responsible. Has anyone experienced this as well? Based on your experience, how can these issues be explained? Are there any proven tips to minimize these problems?

Thank you in advance for your opinions and experiences!
B
BeAndrea
18 May 2021 13:15
semuneo schrieb:
Using thin plastic sleeves to secure the drill holes

That is a very good idea.

Another tip I can recommend: Sometimes it helps to put a little wood glue or construction adhesive into the pre-drilled holes before inserting the metal dowels. This provides better grip for the dowel and also reinforces the side panel.

However, be careful not to spread the glue on the outside of the hole, as this can damage the shelf slightly when inserting the shelves.

We have done this quite often for similar issues at work, and it holds very well.
J
jotisi
18 May 2021 13:42
Guylau schrieb:
Still, I wonder if a simple upgrade, for example with plastic sleeves or reinforced drilling, would be possible and practical

This whole situation is quite a paradox. You get the Billy shelf cheaply and with flexibility, but it’s not really stable. An upgrade sounds good in theory, but no one really knows how to make it practical for the average user.

I stick to my point: for flexible and frequently adjustable shelves, the Billy is simply not the right product, and those who make frequent adjustments should look for higher-quality systems.

The cheapest option isn’t always the best, and this becomes very clear here.