ᐅ House placement on a sloped lot: Where should the house be located?

Created on: 17 May 2024 16:41
K
KrisHoss
Hello,

we have purchased a fully serviced plot of land from the municipality. I have already had it surveyed. The plot is sloped, dropping steeply at the lower right corner. After some consideration, I have identified two possible locations for the house (approximately 70 m² (750 sq ft) footprint with a basement, not yet finalized) with different advantages and disadvantages. Maybe you can help me decide between these options. The expected costs for the site work and earthworks for the two options are the main focus.

Option 1: The house is located at the upper corner of the plot, with the basement fully underground. Here, about 4.5 m (15 ft) of hillside at the lower right corner need to be retained.
Advantage: The house sits high, likely offering a better view over the valley, with a south-facing garden (is this an advantage?)
Disadvantage: In my view, the lower right corner looks unattractive. The steep slope is probably complex and costly to build and maintain.

Option 2: The house is placed at the lower right corner. Here, the house and the hillside garage retain most of the land. The remaining retaining structures are then moderate in height.
Advantage: It appears better integrated into the terrain, with no unnaturally high support structures. Large courtyard on the eaves side.

Development Plan / Restrictions
Plot size: 625 m² (6,725 sq ft)
Slope: yes, steeply sloping at the lower right corner, see elevation plan
Site occupancy index (Grundflächenzahl): 0.4
Floor space index (Geschossflächenzahl): 0.8
Building envelope, building line and boundary: see attachment
Number of parking spaces: 2
Number of stories: 2
Roof type: gable
Maximum heights / limits: eaves height 4.5 m (15 ft). The reference point is not entirely clear to me, see excerpt from the development plan
Additional requirements: retaining walls max 1.2 m (4 ft) above natural ground level

Client Requirements
Basement, stories: fully basement
Number of people, ages: 2 adults, 2 children (2 and 3 years old)
Room requirements on ground floor and upper floor: office and hobby room, location flexible
Office: home office for the wife, possibly private office for the husband
Guest bedrooms per year: rare
Open or closed architecture: rather open

House Design
Designer: terrain plan created by me using freeware, floor plan draft by general contractor, although this is not the main focus of my thread
Cost estimate according to architect/planner: about 460,000 (SF)
Personal budget limit for the house, including fittings: 500,000
Preferred heating system:

As mentioned, in the first step I want to find the best location for the house considering site costs and other factors. Accordingly, the entrance will be either at the eaves or gable side.

I would appreciate your assessments of the options, and maybe someone has a third idea?

Thanks and best regards,

Kris
Grundriss eines Hauses mit Terrasse, Zufahrt, Gehweg und Gartenfläche (Maßangaben).

Weißes Einfamilienhaus auf erhöhter Parzelle mit Spielplatz, Trampolin und Böschung.

Lageplan eines Grundstücks: Haus mit rotem Dach, Terrasse, umlaufende Gartenfläche und Maßlinien

Zweistöckiges Einfamilienhaus mit rotem Dach, gelbem Sockel, Carport und umzäuntem Garten.

Zweistöckiges Haus mit rotem Dach, Einfahrt mit zwei weißen Autos, Trampolin im Garten, weißer Zaun

Architektur Grundriss: farbige Plan-Ansicht von Grundstueck und Gebaeudeaufbau

Text erklärt Bezugspunkt TH/FH als Oberkante der Fertigdecke angrenzender Straßenverkehrsfläche.
Y
ypg
18 May 2024 11:23
I found this here:

Overview plan of a construction area: colored zones (V3, M1, VB), street locations, and green spaces.


Site plan of a new development area with red plots, blue numbers, and street names.


but no written regulations
K
KrisHoss
18 May 2024 12:23
By the way, the utility connections are located at the lower right corner. Somehow, that doesn’t quite match the location at the top left.
K
KrisHoss
18 May 2024 13:19
Diagram for determining eave/ridge height (EH/RH) with N1, WA and height details.


I have the text version. It’s not completely clear whether the reference height is measured at the midpoint of the building length or at the highest point, since there is also a longitudinal slope present. I guess it’s a matter of interpretation..?
H
hanghaus2023
18 May 2024 14:22
I would design it according to my preferences. Unfortunately, the surveyor did not measure the curb line. You should ask them for the elevation at the reference point in the west. I would then position the house and garage 20 cm (8 inches) above the reference point's floor level. This way, you will still have a respectable knee wall height.

How is your neighbor to the west building?

CAD plan of a building plot: blue building area, boundary lines, and dimensions.
H
hanghaus2023
18 May 2024 14:33
How deep is the shaft on the north side of the property? Is there also a sewer shaft in the southeast? Are there any restrictions regarding land shaping and retaining walls?
Y
ypg
18 May 2024 15:30
By the way, this has also been deleted here. Three dots will probably be deleted as well or at least edited by the moderator.

Forum-Thread: YPG profile picture on the left, posts by KrisHoss about PMs and location notice.