ᐅ Architect or Building Contractor?

Created on: 9 Feb 2016 15:27
B
Bayer32
We are still relatively early in our house building project. We have some initial ideas, the plot of land is already secured, and a few sketches...

Many construction companies also create plans or drafts. Do these drafts usually cost anything at construction companies? Especially if you then decide not to go with the company as the builder, or is it free up to a certain point?

Is it more advisable to have a plan created by an architect?

What were your first steps toward creating the plan?
B
Bieber0815
9 Feb 2016 18:53
Order catalogs from three home builders to be sent to your home. If you find something in there that you would accept without changes, have a detailed quote prepared for it. You can also get one from a local general contractor or design-build contractor. If you have your own ideas, consult an architect.

If I owned a plot of land, I would have built with an architect (at least I would have tried to find a suitable one).

Otherwise, definitely follow the advice from Jochen104 (see #4)!
O
ONeill
9 Feb 2016 19:29
BeHaElJa schrieb:
Designs are a service and must be paid for. Large general contractors and certainly some smaller ones often see this service as part of their marketing to attract customers and provide modified catalog floor plans free of charge... unfortunately, the quality is often reflective of that. An architect will expect compensation for this—sometimes a flat fee, sometimes with the offer to credit it if you commission the full project—this is at least our experience.

I actually don’t quite agree with that, at least not in general. We are building with a prefab house supplier and I expected to receive house designs (floor plans, elevations, perspectives) as part of their customer acquisition. Providers who didn’t offer this were unfortunately out of the running. But that was only one out of four. In this industry, investing in customer acquisition is necessary.

For my girlfriend, who is a teacher, this was strange and she felt uneasy about the providers we ultimately didn’t choose. But since I know this process from my own work experience (I once worked five man-days for free), I was familiar with such procedures.

It may be somewhat different with an architect, since they have to create a design from scratch, whereas prefab house suppliers usually work with existing floor plans. But even the supplier we chose fully implemented our desired layout, at least on the ground floor. So the effort probably wasn’t insignificant. It was worthwhile for them in the end, since they were awarded the contract.

Best regards,
Christian
L
Legurit
9 Feb 2016 19:33
As I wrote, it is already available for free... so it is as expected.
D
Doc.Schnaggls
10 Feb 2016 11:50
BeHaElJa schrieb:
As I wrote, there are some for free... accordingly, that is how it is.

Hello,

I wouldn’t quite agree with that.

With our provider, there was a custom design tailored to us and several rounds of revisions before we signed a contract and incurred any costs.

This works with both solid construction and prefabricated house providers.

Regards,

Dirk
L
Legurit
10 Feb 2016 12:03
It is also quite possible that we were just unlucky, or that our plot (second row) and requirements (bedrooms and master bathroom on the ground floor) were somewhat out of the ordinary.
O
ONeill
10 Feb 2016 12:09
It probably depends heavily on the consultant/company, as we have had both experiences. One design was done carelessly with only minor adjustments made. The design from the other provider was genuinely well done.