ᐅ Is the architect's cost estimate realistic?

Created on: 13 May 2024 08:48
P
PascalBW
Hello everyone,

I have received a rough cost estimate for our planned new build from our architect.
How would you assess these costs?
125 m² (1350 ft²) of living space, 3 full floors (no basement), gable roof, semi-detached house, southern Baden-Württemberg.





















































Cost Group Type Cost including VAT in Euros
300 Building structure 434,000
400 Technical installations 125,000
7.1 Architectural services stages 1-4 12,000
7.2 Architectural services stages 5-9 50,000
700 Total Cost Group 700 81,000
N
nordanney
13 May 2024 15:31
PascalBW schrieb:

Of course, the gross floor area (GFA) still does not meet our requirements/expectations because it is still too large, unchanged.

Then the architect should just provide the documents he used to calculate this. Numbers, data, facts (and plans). You can share them here and we will give our (price) feedback.
M
MachsSelbst
13 May 2024 18:23
Does this likable man have a monopoly in the region? If not, maybe you should consider looking for another architect. I mean, you go to him wanting 125m² (1,345 sq ft) and he calculates 180m² (1,938 sq ft) for you.

That would be like going to a car dealership, giving your budget, saying you want a compact car, and the salesperson takes you to a 5 Series BMW that’s 50% over your budget. My natural reaction would be to leave the dealership because I couldn’t see any basis for that...

If it starts like this, it’s no fun to constantly question everything the architect does afterward, wondering if it actually fits. Or if maybe he opened the wrong plan while drunk again and the guest bathroom ends up being 18m² (194 sq ft), but the kitchen only 4m² (43 sq ft).

An experienced architect should notice that the basic figures simply don’t add up. 910m³ (32,139 cu ft). Architects aren’t engineers, but they should definitely have enough sense of measurements and plausibility...
A
AlterFalter
19 May 2024 11:14
PascalBW schrieb:






7.6 Geotechnical report 2500

€2500 for a geotechnical report is quite steep. I paid €1100 last week for three boreholes...
J
Jentopa
24 May 2024 09:26
Keep it short and save yourself time: Find another architect...