ᐅ Gas fireplace, but heating with a heat pump?!

Created on: 15 Sep 2019 19:54
J
j1985
Hello,

we are still at the very beginning of our planning. However, I have always found gas fireplaces very attractive and also practical. In our floor plan, it would also fit well as a room divider.

The main reason for choosing one would be the cozy atmosphere it creates, not the heating aspect.

When comparing gas fireplaces and wood-burning fireplaces, I personally see more advantages with a gas fireplace!

However, considering today’s context (discussion about CO2 taxes, KfW subsidies, etc.), it seems wiser not to rely on a gas boiler but rather on a heat pump, which we would currently prefer over a gas boiler.

On the other hand, it would be quite costly to install a gas line just for a gas fireplace.

I am currently quite conflicted because a wood-burning fireplace is not really a great alternative for us.

Has anyone been in the same situation? How did you decide? Are there any helpful tips?

Thanks in advance.
hausnrplus2510 Apr 2020 10:39
nordanney schrieb:

No. Air-to-water heat pump and gas fireplace with a bottle, or an actual real fire (which requires a proper chimney, which is also expensive).

Installing a chimney for a wood-burning fireplace costs around €3500-5000 (about $3800-$5400).
And with an air-to-water heat pump, you actually don’t need one.
Zaba12 schrieb:

Since I’ve been here, I’ve never heard of such a price. The gas connection is the most expensive connection of all.

I think it also depends on how long the connection route is.
We know prices around €2500 (about $2700).

Whether the cost of firewood or gas prices differ obviously depends on how you source the wood.

We are currently facing the same decision. We both grew up with a fireplace/stove, love the warmth and coziness. Financially, though, it’s an incredibly expensive luxury given that you don’t really need the heat with a heat pump and underfloor heating.

So far, the idea of a gas fireplace has also discouraged us because of the line installation costs (which you fortunately save with a heat pump). We will research the idea of gas bottles further.

Has anyone else had good experiences with an electric fireplace?
What are the advantages and disadvantages compared to a gas fireplace?
Neither of us has seen either in person.
N
nordanney
10 Apr 2020 11:32
hausnrplus25 schrieb:

Has anyone had good experiences with an electric fireplace?
What are the pros and cons compared to a gas fireplace?
We are not familiar with either in person.

This is not a fireplace. No real fire. No atmosphere. You might as well sit down and turn on a space heater with a flashlight shining on it.
R
Rosthaus
11 Apr 2020 09:49
Zaba12 schrieb:

Since I’ve been here, I’ve never heard of a price like that. The gas connection is the most expensive of all connections.
But in our case, that’s actually true. They are now competing hard for gas customers.