ᐅ Interpreting Structural Calculations for a Garage (Reinforcement…) Correctly

Created on: 11 Aug 2025 14:51
I
Ilchbart
I
Ilchbart
11 Aug 2025 14:51
Dear all,

We have an old house (built in 1924 with an extension from 1994) and always too little space (5–6 people)!
Therefore, a second garage is planned, which I want to build together with my neighbor (a mason).
The structural calculation is available; I wanted to order the materials tomorrow, but unfortunately, the structural engineer is now on vacation.
Could you please tell me based on the photos how many reinforcement mats I need for the ceiling and exactly where they should be placed? Neither the mason nor the building materials supplier could give me a definite answer. So I hope you can help me.

Thank you very much!
Technische Seite Stahlbetondecke Feld 1 mit Auflagern A/B Länge 3,50 m Diagramm und Tabellen

Technische Berechnungsseite mit Tabellen zu Biegung, Querkraft und Bewehrung (Feld 1: Q335A).

Technische Zeichnung: Längsbewehrung (Q335A) mit Diagramm oben/unten und rotem Bewehrungsbereich.

Grundriss einer Garage mit Bewehrung, Stahlbetondecke, Abmessungen ca. 3,5 m, Neubau Garage.
A
ajokr2025
11 Aug 2025 16:01
He did attach the installation plan after all:
For the ceiling, 3 mats of Q335 reinforcement on the top and the same amount on the bottom. Concrete cover should also be noted somewhere.
For the floor slab, Q257 reinforcement on top.
I
Ilchbart
11 Aug 2025 20:19
Thank you in advance.
On page 3, it looks like he only wants a full layer of reinforcement at the bottom of the slab and steel only around the edges at the top. At the bottom of page 3, the mats are also specified with a width of only 1.08 m (3.5 feet).
However, the drawing at the bottom of page 4 suggests he wants two full layers of reinforcement in the slab.
Strange, everyone I ask gives a different answer. 😉
A
ajokr2025
11 Aug 2025 20:34
Yes, structurally the reinforcement is required at the bottom center. For design reasons, 0.80 cm²/m (0.52 in²/ft) has been calculated at the top edges. For simplicity, the Q335 steel has then been arranged continuously at the top and bottom. This also prevents shrinkage cracks at the top surface.
For larger spans, the mesh selection would be adjusted accordingly.
I
Ilchbart
11 Aug 2025 22:00
Thanks. Now I finally understand it 🙂
H
HWTIGGER
18 Aug 2025 01:34
The calculation is actually incorrect. The concrete cover is set too low, as we are not inside a building. XC1 is incorrect, so the reinforcement also changes.