ᐅ Local heating network or heat pump – advice and experiences?

Created on: 1 Aug 2022 13:03
S
se_na_23
We are currently deciding between district heating and an air-to-water heat pump...
Our house will be built on a slab foundation according to the KfW55 standard and has a total area of 155 sqm (1,669 sq ft), including the technical room.

The district heating (biogas) costs are as follows:

Connection fee (one-time): €7,794.50
Annual basic charge: €416.50
Energy price per kWh: €0.893 – fixed price until 12/31/2031

The lump sum price from the general contractor (GC) already includes a stratified water storage tank and fresh water station.
If we choose an air-to-water heat pump (from Buderus), the GC charges an additional €12,111.

Unfortunately, we do not yet know our heating load. A budget for photovoltaic panels will probably not be available in the first five years.

Can anyone with expertise help us decide what to do or advise where we can seek consultation?
We are quite uncertain.

Thank you very much.
Patricck25 Sep 2022 18:10
se_na_23 schrieb:

Really affordable... At our price, 18000 kWh is quite a lot... I could almost heat with gas instead.
Plus heating maintenance, plus chimney sweep, plus a huge unit in the basement. If you have access to district heating, that is currently the most comfortable and sustainable solution.
se_na_2325 Sep 2022 19:18
But unfortunately not the cheapest option for us 🙁
Patricck25 Sep 2022 20:14
I didn’t fully understand your cost calculation, perhaps not the initial investment, but probably over the years.
se_na_2325 Sep 2022 20:42
Well, first we have to pay a connection fee of 7,800 (7,800) ... Then, according to the technical specifications sheet (TAB), a storage tank plus a fresh water station for 5,600 (5,600)...

So, the basic costs amount to 13,400 (13,400).
Ongoing costs are a 416 Euro (416 USD approx.) basic charge plus just under 9 cents per kilowatt-hour...

Considering your consumption and our price, I estimate heating costs of 2,023 Euro (2,023 USD approx.) per year, which I find clearly too high for a new house...
Patricck25 Sep 2022 20:56
But how much does a heat pump plus storage tank cost? Or a gas heating system?
Then you have to calculate the annual running costs: electricity for the heat pump, gas for the gas heater, chimney sweep, chimney maintenance, servicing, etc.

With district heating, just electricity for the pumps... that's it.

For us, the connection cost was also around 13,000 euros (including the transfer station)

And you would need a hot water boiler in any case.
se_na_2325 Sep 2022 21:56
The heat pump with a 190-liter (50-gallon) tank would cost €12,111...

And even in summer, I constantly have 600 liters (160 gallons) of hot water in the house even though the heating is not running... It keeps being heated continuously.