ᐅ Plot of Land: Opportunity or Burden?

Created on: 21 Oct 2017 09:30
I
Interpolis
Hello,

I have a fundamental question about purchasing land that is not focused on the financial aspect but rather on the general principle:

The situation is as follows:
My wife and I have wanted to move back to our hometown (about 15,000 inhabitants), located 40 kilometers (25 miles) east of Frankfurt, for some time now. We started looking for a plot this summer and did not expect to find one so quickly. We are now close to buying what we consider a dream plot, exactly as we had always imagined. The plot is almost square, located in a (significantly) upscale, well-established residential area, at the edge of a forest, flat terrain, with a view into the valley. From what I can see in the city’s cadastral plans, it is one of the last plots of its kind. All other available plots in the established neighborhoods have significant drawbacks in terms of location or shape, in our opinion. The areas designated by the city as building land / planning permission zones have plots sized between 450 and 550 square meters (about 4,800 to 5,900 square feet). These are too small for us, and we do not want to move into a new development where there will be construction noise for the next ten years.

The price per square meter of our plot is 200 euros. The city’s plots are priced between 150 and 170 euros per square meter. My wife and I are aware that a plot of this type and quality in our hometown might not be available again anytime soon, or possibly never. The real estate agent told us, however, that the plot has been on the market for six years. He had many viewings, and all interested parties admired the property, but according to the agent, the price for this area is considered “luxury level,” especially since the city offers much cheaper alternatives.

Here is our problem: We want the plot. But we cannot say with 100% certainty whether we will build on it ourselves. I would estimate the probability at 80 to 90 percent. The reason is that I currently work as a civil servant in the state capital, which is 90 kilometers (56 miles) away from the plot, but a transfer to a nearby office is possible. However, my employer has selected me for career advancement opportunities. I am currently seconded to a ministry and will be there for at least another one and a half years, if all goes well. Every additional day there improves my career prospects. Career advancement, however, in a large federal state also means geographical flexibility. So, I cannot say for sure where I might be assigned. On the other hand, I could also decide against pursuing a career and move to a local office near the plot at any time. It would also be possible to balance career and building on the plot, as there are enough promotion opportunities in the surrounding area.

Given these circumstances, would you buy the plot? We can cover the purchase price (about 180,000 euros in total including all additional costs) from our own capital. My concern is the possibility that we might suddenly be relocated elsewhere for work. This worries me because the agent said he couldn’t sell the plot for six years due to the price. Therefore, I wonder whether we would be able to sell the plot without a loss and whether there is any chance of making even a small profit. I have two siblings who both live in our hometown and intend to stay. Both will likely need to buy plots within the next five years. It might be possible to sell it to one of them. I also have some hope because of the proximity to Frankfurt (the connection is very good, with train station and highway). In a nearby town (about 10 kilometers / 6 miles closer to Frankfurt), comparable plots already cost more than 200,000 euros. If Brexit goes through, prices will probably rise further.

In short: I am thinking about whether this plot should be seen as an opportunity for returning home or as a burden considering our (professional) future.

I would appreciate any input.
11ant22 Oct 2017 14:26
[P.S. / Timeout Edit]

Without the introductory comment
Interpolis schrieb:
My wife and I have been hoping for some time to move back to our hometown
I would, however, have a somewhat different view on this, since in my opinion, purely for speculative purposes, it only really makes sense on a larger scale.
https://www.instagram.com/11antgmxde/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/bauen-jetzt/
M
miho
23 Oct 2017 13:05
Alex85 schrieb:
You really think Grey’s Anatomy is about surgery? ;-)

So, you believe it can be done cheaper. Okay, maybe. But what is your idea of how cheap it can get, so that at €16.50/sq m (about $18/sq yd) there’s even a cent left in the village budget?
There’s nothing left at all; on the contrary, the administrative effort afterwards is a loss-making business. It’s only done to attract people to the village, no matter the cost.

But that’s a good thing. Especially if the village still has good infrastructure, you have to try to use and preserve it. And for that, you need young people who want to stay there. In the long run, this will surely bring benefits to the community.
11ant23 Oct 2017 13:27
miho schrieb:
And for that, you need young people who want to stay there. In the long term, the community will definitely benefit from this.
If maintaining primary schools in the area follows on from providing these plots, then yes. Because in the long run, the community mainly benefits when young people have even younger generations.
https://www.instagram.com/11antgmxde/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/bauen-jetzt/
M
miho
23 Oct 2017 13:29
11ant schrieb:
If the plots also include the preservation of local primary schools, then yes.

I completely agree with you. Unfortunately, this is a common issue in that area. I hope the situation is better at that specific location.
11ant23 Oct 2017 13:46
miho schrieb:
And unfortunately, this is generally a problem in that area.

Where exactly? In Saxon Siberia or in the outskirts of Mainhattan?

At the moment, I tend to see it more in the spatial planning "middle layers" (that is, neither metropolitan areas nor very remote regions), where the district towns weaken the surrounding suburban municipalities by closing their elementary schools.
https://www.instagram.com/11antgmxde/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/bauen-jetzt/
N
Nordlys
23 Oct 2017 14:07
Successful new residential developments in villages can help save primary schools and kindergartens. However, these areas often also attract many older adults seeking peace and a rural setting.
In Schleswig-Holstein, this is complemented by another measure: the elimination of school districts (school zones). Parents can send their child to any primary school they choose, but they must arrange transportation themselves. Free school buses only operate within the original district. The result is that village primary schools that have developed a specific profile manage to stay open. In contrast, city schools without a clear profile, often with a high proportion of migrant children, struggle to attract students. Market forces rather than planning. At one point, during Peter Harry Carstensen’s administration, the FDP was in charge of the Ministry of Education. Karsten