ᐅ Which of the two floor plans is better?

Hello,

I would like to know which of the two floor plans you prefer.

One floor plan has a straight staircase (small open gallery), and the other features a half-turn staircase. Unfortunately, all staircases have their pros and cons.

Also, do you think the hallway might be too large?

It is clear that the hallway is potentially too large.
I would choose the option without the study because the version with the study uses space for a room that is not accessible (no door).

What does the upper floor look like in this regard? It’s best to start planning from the top.

Charlie90 schrieb:

I would like to know which of the two floor plans you think is better.
One floor plan has a straight staircase (small open gallery), and the second one has a half-turn staircase.

First of all, "thank you" for the computer crash when viewing the floor plans that are six and a half square meters (70 sq ft) in size :-(
This initially shows that you are using an unsuitable design program. Keep in mind that not only are gigapixel images difficult for other participants to view, but also that the masons will only be working with 1.3 dpi resolution at full scale—so this "precision" is completely pointless.

I don’t want to "critique" your floor plans in detail yet, because the main flaw has already been pointed out by the previous poster: these are ground floors only, which is the least suitable starting point.

By the way, staircase types not only have their pros and cons compared to each other, but they always have a central and defining influence on the overall floor plan. A straight single-flight staircase is, in a way, the "pain in the neck" of a floor plan. With just a few other factors, you can easily create an unmanageable layout if you start planning from the wrong end.

After you have studied the plot and can approach the floor plans, it’s best to begin without any drawings at all, but with a table. In this table, list the rooms and then "qualify" them with their approximate floor areas. Then assign them to the floors. The "weight" of the areas on the lists "GF" and "UF" should roughly have a ratio of 50:50 ("urban villa") or 65:35 ("one-and-a-half-story house").

Once you have achieved this balance, start with the upper floor and develop its layout first. The ground floor then follows this arrangement. This rule assumes an entrance on the ground floor; with sloped plots, you need to adjust the approach. The strictness of this method also depends on the load-bearing walls.

If your design is largely based on an existing template, it is helpful to mention the original model in the discussion (no link!), and describe the variations (e.g., three-child family or two home offices).

---

https://www.instagram.com/11antgmxde/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/bauen-jetzt/

Charlie90 schrieb:

I would like to know which of the two floor plans you think is better.

"I wanted to ask which car you prefer..."
Under what requirements? Omitting a home office only makes sense if you actually don’t need one. Otherwise, it has to go upstairs. And if you work from home four days a week, you might want more than just a storage closet 😉
There is a questionnaire in this forum that you can use as a starting point and then possibly present the new result. With questionnaire.

I would first like to see the plot of land. The site plan and photos of the surroundings.

Having so few windows doesn’t make sense.

I have arranged the floor plans in a simpler layout for easier viewing.