ᐅ Garage insulation cannot be installed

Created on: 29 Aug 2017 23:25
M
Marchonisch
Hi.

We had a garage built with concrete walls. One side is buried about 1 to 2 meters (3 to 6.5 feet) underground (the left side when looking from front to back). Since the garage is directly adjacent to the neighbor’s property, our structural builder said he could not install insulation or drainage membranes. The architect also said he sees no problem with this. However, an acquaintance strongly advises us to avoid this approach...

What do you think? Thanks

Außenansicht eines Rohbaufundaments aus Beton mit Erdreich und Rohr an der Kellerwand.


Gras und Unkraut wachsen am Fundament einer Gebäudewand im Außenbereich.
B
Bieber0815
22 Sep 2017 10:42
Marchonisch schrieb:
To dig, I would need access to the neighbor’s property. They have already planted and installed paving stones there.

You can either do it properly now, or take another approach, but then it will just be... :P

The inadequate construction planning (if it was even possible to install the waterproofing before the neighbor’s paving and landscaping work) only makes it more expensive, but not impossible.

What else could be clarified:
What was agreed upon, and what is the architect actually responsible for? What do the detailed garage plans specify here (waterproofing, insulation) and why?
11ant22 Sep 2017 12:04
Marchonisch schrieb:
The property ends at the concrete wall of the garage. To dig, I would need access to the neighbor’s area.

Anyone planning a garage right on the boundary must check whether the neighboring property’s elevation matches accordingly.
Marchonisch schrieb:
The neighbor has already planted there and laid paving stones.

Then the planner should prepare to restore that. If they fail to coordinate this properly, they should cover any additional costs.
Marchonisch schrieb:
That’s why I’m asking if something can be done from the inside.

No, as already mentioned in post #8, that is not possible. Leaving out the waterproofing against penetrating surface water precisely where it is most likely to occur (since, as you can clearly see, the water does not simply drain vertically but runs down the garage wall first) would be unwise. Trying to "trap" this trickle from the inside would only lead to a damp wall.

Structurally, I see no alternative to open excavation from the neighbor’s side. The insulation must be applied all the way down; there is no way around this. Look up “right to hammer” (hammering rights). You must exempt the neighbor from all costs, and your planner must arrange this before starting the external work on the neighbor’s property, especially if they overlooked it. The insulation can always be applied after the wall has been fully constructed—you should expect an architect to understand the spatial implications this has for a partially earth-retained garage.
https://www.instagram.com/11antgmxde/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/bauen-jetzt/
B
Bau-Schmidt
24 Sep 2017 13:08
Marchonisch schrieb:
You basically can’t access it from the outside anymore. Only from the inside some work could still be done.
Ladder and hammer rights apply here. Apparently, the architect is building their first house.