ᐅ Floor Plan Design and Placement – Single-Family Home of Approximately 200 m² on a 900 m² Plot

Created on: 4 May 2021 20:49
S
Samantheus
Hello everyone,

we would like to get feedback on our current planning for a single-family house. Here is the completed questionnaire.

Development Plan / Restrictions
Plot size: 911m² (9,800 sq ft)
Slope: no
Site coverage ratio: 0.3
Floor area ratio: 0.45
Building envelope, building line and boundary
Edge development: garage only
Number of parking spaces: 4
Number of floors: 2
Roof shape: gable roof
Architectural style:
Orientation: The garden faces southwest, the house is about 5m (16 ft) from the street, parallel to the street
Maximum heights / limits
Other requirements

Owners’ Requirements
Architectural style, roof shape, building type: single-family house, modern, gable roof main building, green flat roof extension and garage
Basement, floors: basement, ground floor, upper floor
Number of people, age: currently 2 adults (mid-30s), 1 small child; planned for 2 adults and 2–3 children
Space requirements on ground and upper floors: see floor plan
Office: home office (working professionally from home, 2 offices required)
Guests per year:
Open or closed architecture: open
Conservative or modern construction: modern
Open kitchen, cooking island: open kitchen in U-shape with counter or kitchen with cooking island
Number of dining places: 6
Fireplace: optional, rather not
Music / stereo wall: yes
Balcony, roof terrace: no
Garage, carport: double garage with two parking spaces in front (currently 1 car, possibly 2 in the future)
Utility garden, greenhouse: only recreational garden
Other wishes / special features / daily routine, including reasons why certain things should or should not be: Professional work from home, therefore two large offices are required. The plot is a corner lot on two streets, so the L-shaped house design aims to shield somewhat from the streets and create a protected garden area. If a third child arrives, one office should be converted into a third child’s bedroom. Then a small office area will be separated off in the master bedroom with a drywall partition or a basement room will be finished.

House Design
Who is responsible for the design: planner from a construction company (with some do-it-yourself input)
What do you particularly like? Why?: 2 equally sized children’s bedrooms, 2 offices with enough space for full-time work (>40 hours per week), large living/dining/kitchen area, extension provides light and noise protection from the street
What do you dislike? Why?: staircase ends at front door, which might lead to dirt being carried inside
Price estimate according to architect/planner: about 700k for KfW 55 standard including garage and basement, solid construction
Personal price limit for house including fittings: about 800k including exterior landscaping
Preferred heating system: air-to-water heat pump

In the living/dining/kitchen area, the kitchen should be U-shaped with a counter or a cooking island on the far left. Afterwards comes the dining area, then the sofa. The stereo system with large floor-standing speakers should be on the wall opposite the kitchen. The extension should house a piano and a tipi (children’s play tent). Alternatively, the sofa could be placed in the bottom right corner and the speakers at the end of the extension.
The offices should have space for a large desk (2m x 1m (6.5 ft x 3.3 ft)), a bookshelf wall, and a small seating area.

If you have to give up something, which details / expansions
-can you give up: fireplace / stove
-can you not give up: offices

Why is the design the way it is now?

Combination of our suggestions and ideas from the planner during a joint site visit

What is the most important / fundamental question about the floor plan summarized in 130 characters?

The most important in 130 characters:
  • Is the floor plan good from your perspective, or have we overlooked something important?


Detailed questions about the floor plan:
  • Does the entrance area seem too large?
  • Do you have alternative ideas for designing the staircase better (we are currently considering either a U-shaped staircase with landing or an L-shaped staircase with landing)? We had a version drawn with an entrance bay so the staircase doesn't end right at the door. But that costs more and might make the entrance area too large?
  • We are still considering reducing the number of windows in the living/dining/kitchen area. What do you think? We are afraid it might get too hot in summer because of the southern orientation (external blinds are planned).
  • Another consideration is external roller shutters or blinds on the upper floor?
  • Regarding the living room layout, we’re unsure. On one hand, we want two large floor-standing speakers optimally placed for a stereo triangle, on the other hand, we want to have a view of the garden from the sofa.
  • About the windows on the upper floor, we're unsure: Does a floor-to-ceiling window make sense in the children’s rooms, or is it rather a safety risk? We have planned a window next to the bed (on the same wall as the head of the bed). I'm unsure if that might look strange in reality or if the bed should be placed on the opposite wall (but then the headboard would face the children’s room window).

Questions about placement:
  • There is a busy street at the bottom side and a less busy street on the right side. Currently, the house is about 5m (16 ft) from the busy street and 8m (26 ft) from the right street. If we move the house further upwards, we would have more quiet from the street, but the garden would become smaller and the "wasted front garden area" would increase. What do you think?
  • Do you have any creative ideas to shift or stretch the house further to the right? On the left side is a garage, which we would like to build directly onto.


Option 1:

Modern white single-family house with garage, entrance, garden and roses in the foreground

White, modern two-story villa with large glass windows and garden flowers.

Modern white villa with side flat-roof extension, garden and flowers in foreground.


Basement floor plan: hallway connects four basement rooms, building services.

House floor plan: open living/dining/kitchen area, office, hallway, stairs, garage

House floor plan with hallway, bathroom, children’s rooms and bedroom


Option 2:

Modern two-story house with large garage, entrance area and garden

House floor plan: open kitchen, living/dining/kitchen, two offices, hallway, WC, storage room


Placement:

Floor plan of a house with garage, several rooms, stairs and measurements



Thank you in advance!

Best regards
Samantheus
Y
ypg
28 Jun 2021 10:05
Samantheus schrieb:

Since there was no further input regarding drainage, I assume that you consider the potentially critical issues to be resolved.

I believe I had mentioned something about this (the drawing shows pipes WITHIN the walls) – so there is nothing more to add, as you should pay attention to that. We can’t act as your expert and comment on every detail.

Regarding the staircase: I previously preferred it when you could see the dining room from the entrance.
I would also have preferred the staircase placed so that the parents’ bathroom is on the left, the children’s bathroom on the right, and the walk-in closet between the bathroom and bedroom, serving as a passage to the bedroom.
face2628 Jun 2021 12:11
Samantheus schrieb:

Since there was no further input regarding drainage, I assume that the potentially critical issues you mentioned have been resolved.

Are you satisfied with the bathroom layout as it is?
The toilet in the master bathroom will be fixed in place. You won’t be able to move it around much later. And, as predicted, it has now shifted to the other side. With a chase wall in the office, right?

I don’t have enough time right now to look at the details more closely.

Will there still only be a small washbasin in the master bathroom?

I find the bathtub placement a bit odd. But maybe that’s just my personal taste.

Edit: Now I finally get it. The toilet’s waste pipe makes a 90-degree bend. Well... it’s not very elegant.
11ant28 Jun 2021 12:37
Why is there always a roughly defined building envelope shown in your ground floor plans?
https://www.instagram.com/11antgmxde/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/bauen-jetzt/
H
hanghaus2000
28 Jun 2021 12:59
In the first post, no building boundaries are marked. The only requirement was a 5 m (16 feet) distance from the street. In my opinion, it was still unclear whether it is even approvable according to the development plan.

Has the building authority already provided a response to the preliminary building inquiry?
S
Samantheus
28 Jun 2021 13:56
Thank you very much for your responses.

We have now decided to go with the original option, featuring an open line of sight from the entrance area through to the garden. Many thanks for your advice and opinions.
face26 schrieb:

With a front wall box in the office, right?
Two options were drafted: one with a front wall box in the office and an alternative with a front wall in the bathroom.
face26 schrieb:

Will that still work with a small washbasin in the master bathroom?
We don’t want a huge double washbasin or anything like that. Possibly something a bit larger than standard, but not so large that the space might feel cramped.
11ant schrieb:

Why is there always a roughly defined building boundary drawn in your ground floors?
The development plan is very old. The neighboring property has a similar building boundary, but their house was built parallel to the street with about 5m (16 feet) distance, so also not within the building boundary—just like our planned house. A non-binding preliminary inquiry indicated that aligning the orientation with the neighbors to maintain a uniform streetscape, rather than strictly following the development plan, is generally supported.
M
Myrna_Loy
28 Jun 2021 13:58
Samantheus schrieb:

Since there have been no further comments regarding drainage, I assume that the points you considered potentially critical have been addressed.

Today, I also received the drawing for Alternative 2, which involves swapping the master bedroom area with the children’s area, as well as switching the staircase and entrance. At first glance, I don’t see any major strengths or weaknesses in either version. It will probably come down to having an open entrance area with a view axis versus a closed entrance area with privacy, which is largely a matter of personal preference.

I have attached the images in case you notice anything else.

Elevations


Floor Plans

This oversized canopy just looks bulky and out of scale. With the floor-to-ceiling window and the fall protection above the bathroom window, this unnecessary structure and the cluttered appearance of the façade are only emphasized further. It reminds me of the columns that were often stuck to the entrances in the 1980s and 1990s to try to enhance the houses.