Hello,
I was shocked by the news about the six young people who died.
I’m wondering if something like this could happen in our case, since we have a newly built house with a fireplace and small children.
We don’t have any mechanical ventilation or similar systems; the fireplace is only used for cozy atmosphere and occasional heating. When it gets too warm, we tilt the window open.
We burn regular wood. Could something like this happen to us as well? The local chimney sweep included a note on the last invoice that he is happy to inform about and install carbon monoxide detectors.
What do you think about these concerns?
I was shocked by the news about the six young people who died.
I’m wondering if something like this could happen in our case, since we have a newly built house with a fireplace and small children.
We don’t have any mechanical ventilation or similar systems; the fireplace is only used for cozy atmosphere and occasional heating. When it gets too warm, we tilt the window open.
We burn regular wood. Could something like this happen to us as well? The local chimney sweep included a note on the last invoice that he is happy to inform about and install carbon monoxide detectors.
What do you think about these concerns?
B
Bieber08152 Feb 2017 10:35ypg schrieb:
When the fireplace is burning, the risk of excessive CO formation is very low because CO forms in higher amounts when there is insufficient oxygen. When the fire is burning, there is enough oxygen. Yes and no. It is true that in a "proper" fireplace fire, the combustion primarily proceeds completely to CO2. However, some CO will inevitably be produced when burning wood.In my opinion, the real danger does not lie in the type of combustion (complete/incomplete) but in inadequate ventilation of the flue gases. If the chimney is blocked, dampers are not operated correctly, or ventilation/extraction systems are not properly integrated with the fireplace, flue gases can enter the living space. That is when it becomes dangerous (even if the combustion appears to be complete).
Regarding the placement of the CO detector, my assumption was that the fireplace is only in use when the occupants are nearby (sitting on the tiger skin in front of it). Therefore, I do not see a need for a CO detector at a distance from the fireplace. However, this should definitely be decided on a case-by-case basis.
With proper use of the fireplace (which also includes regular maintenance), I do not see any risk from CO.
Personally, as a neighbor of fireplace owners, what bothers me is only the fine dust and the typical smell ;-).
Two acquaintances have already told us that there have been multiple occasions where fog-like smoke formed on the floor from the stove.
The external air pressure pushed the exhaust gases back into the interior.
Ultimately, this seems to be caused by improper use of the stove.
However, you don’t live alone, and especially children don’t always understand everything—they just want to know where the control is to make the flame bigger = warmer.
It can happen from time to time that someone becomes careless, falls asleep, or closes a window again...
For indoor heating appliances, I would always recommend installing appropriate warning devices. They cost nothing and don’t cause any inconvenience. Why argue about it?
The external air pressure pushed the exhaust gases back into the interior.
Ultimately, this seems to be caused by improper use of the stove.
However, you don’t live alone, and especially children don’t always understand everything—they just want to know where the control is to make the flame bigger = warmer.
It can happen from time to time that someone becomes careless, falls asleep, or closes a window again...
For indoor heating appliances, I would always recommend installing appropriate warning devices. They cost nothing and don’t cause any inconvenience. Why argue about it?
Hello
I’m just seeing this thread now.
After extensive research and some expert advice, I decided to go with the Abus.
Installation: in the living room (where the tile stove is) at a height of 170cm (67 inches) and 180cm (71 inches) away from the stove. The device is quite loud and is supposed to provide precise measurements. After 7 years, it indicates by itself that it needs replacement. Costs between 50 and 60 euros.
Steven
I’m just seeing this thread now.
After extensive research and some expert advice, I decided to go with the Abus.
Installation: in the living room (where the tile stove is) at a height of 170cm (67 inches) and 180cm (71 inches) away from the stove. The device is quite loud and is supposed to provide precise measurements. After 7 years, it indicates by itself that it needs replacement. Costs between 50 and 60 euros.
Steven
Similar topics