ᐅ Developer or Architect – Costs

Created on: 6 Mar 2016 19:28
E
Elisabeth78
Hello everyone,

My partner and I would like to build a solid, masonry house (or have it built) with about 140 square meters (1500 square feet), including a basement and a garage. We have already visited two local home builders, but both only carry out a small portion of the trades themselves and subcontract the rest.

Now we are wondering if it might be more cost-effective to plan the construction ourselves with an architect and request individual quotes for each trade. How much can you typically save this way, and is it advisable for us as novices to plan the project on our own, or is the risk of making mistakes too high?

Thank you.
Jochen1047 Mar 2016 08:25
Besides the cost aspect, you should always keep an eye on quality as well.
W
Wastl
7 Mar 2016 08:38
The risk of exceeding the estimated construction budget by 20% is significantly higher with an architect compared to a general contractor with a fixed-price offer.
W
world-e
7 Mar 2016 08:53
I attended a lecture over the weekend where this topic was also discussed. It became clear that it is impossible to make a general statement about it. With a general contractor (GC) or main contractor, architectural services are included, which you have to pay for. The GC’s costs include their production expenses, plus additional sales costs, operating costs, profit, and so on. When working directly with an architect, you pay for their architectural services. However, it also depends heavily on the architect’s skills in obtaining offers and negotiating or comparing prices. If you have one who is not willing to handle this, you end up covering the costs yourself. I don’t mean to speak badly of architects, as most of them certainly work diligently. But there are always a few bad apples everywhere.
L
Legurit
7 Mar 2016 08:55
It doesn’t even have to be black; a cozy light gray is perfectly fine as well.
V
Vanben
7 Mar 2016 09:00
World-e schrieb:
You pay your architect for their architectural services. However, it also depends heavily on the architect’s ability to obtain quotes and negotiate/compare prices. If you have one who isn’t willing to do that, you end up covering those costs yourself.

I lack personal experience, but isn’t exactly that supposed to be ensured by commissioning service phase 7? This isn’t a matter of “willingness”; it’s a clearly defined, chargeable service.
L
Legurit
7 Mar 2016 09:03
It is probably about the fact that an architect may have contractors they have worked well with for years, who might be somewhat more expensive.