ᐅ Wired Connection vs. Telecom Fiber Optic – Making the Choice

Created on: 26 Apr 2021 14:56
K
kgeisler
Hello everyone,

At the risk of asking a really basic question, we are currently facing the decision of whether to order cable (Vodafone) or Telekom fiber optic FTTH for our new development. We want to completely give up traditional TV connections (so from our point of view, we don’t need satellite or cable per se) and instead do everything via streaming. Therefore, for us, only performance, future-proofing, or price if performance is similar, matter.

However, we are finding it difficult to decide or to break down the costs.

Telekom definitely provides fiber all the way into the house, so the performance here is certainly the best. Monthly costs after new customer bonuses, etc., are about 90 EUR (around 90 USD) for the full gigabit.

For cable, I can’t get anyone on the phone who can tell me if their fiber also goes all the way into the house; if it does, would the performance be equivalent, or am I mistaken?

For cable, there is usually a cable fee of 21 EUR (about 21 USD), or am I wrong? Or does this only apply if you actually take cable TV, and otherwise it doesn’t have to be paid?

Then cable would be clearly cheaper with 75 EUR (about 75 USD) for the last mile. Otherwise slightly more expensive.

Has anyone faced a similar decision? What did you decide and why?

Thank you!
H
hanse987
30 Dec 2021 11:12
If you ever think about Magenta TV in the future, make sure to get a network switch that supports IGMPv3.
A
AllThumbs
30 Dec 2021 11:20
hanse987 schrieb:

If you ever consider Magenta TV in the future, go for a network switch that supports IGMPv3 right away.

Is this still an issue with Ubiquiti devices?
N
Nordlys
30 Dec 2021 12:25
We chose the 50,000 contract, which is sufficient for HD TV plus simultaneous internet browsing. For the satellite dish, do not install it on the roof, but rather, for example, on the carport roof or a similar location. This makes replacing the LNB very easy.
Tarnari30 Dec 2021 13:23
AllThumbs schrieb:

Is this still an issue with the Ubiquiti devices?

Yes, it is. Because of this, I had to set up a router cascade and separate the networks:
Internet connection -> Fritzbox -> Telekom receiver, Gigaset Go Box, and Sunny Home Manager -> Dream Machine Pro -> switch for the rest of the house wiring.
There was no other way.
11ant30 Dec 2021 14:46
Pumpernickel1 schrieb:

We have said goodbye to cable. The ongoing monthly costs that will last a lifetime just scare us here.
About 25 euros ... where can you still find a connection noticeably cheaper?
https://www.instagram.com/11antgmxde/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/bauen-jetzt/
Mahri2330 Dec 2021 14:57
We decided to use a satellite dish on the roof for TV reception. I can reach the LNB directly through the large skylight without having to go onto the roof. I waited for the city utilities to install fiber optics to our house before setting up the internet connection. It has been running at 100 Mbit/s since August. Since we are in a subsidized area, the connection was free for us. Saved 1800 euros. 🙂