ᐅ Botched Work in the Attic – Are the Wooden Beams Misaligned?

Hello everyone,

Two months ago, my family bought a used prefabricated house (built in 2018), and we have now noticed some very unprofessional work in the attic. At least, that’s how it appears to us (unfortunately, we don’t have much construction knowledge).

I am attaching a few pictures related to this.

What do you think? Does it really look quite uneven? Could this negatively affect the long-term structural stability? And if so, would this be considered a defect for which the homeowner has up to five years to report to the construction company and request repairs?

Thank you very much in advance.

Best regards, Martin

This beam is crooked, that’s not an illusion. Whether it was poorly installed, incorrectly shaped during prefabrication, or the wood warped due to the long time between delivery and construction – who knows, all of this is possible. If it were just one beam, I wouldn’t have structural concerns. It’s definitely not aesthetically pleasing, though.
Are you sure that the prefabricated house was assembled by a company?

Could it be that the same so-called "premium provider" was involved here as with @flavahBS in https://www.hausbau-forum.de/threads/pfusch-beim-zusammenbau-des-dachgeruestes.38570/?

---

https://www.instagram.com/11antgmxde/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/bauen-jetzt/

mcwaldi schrieb:

Hello everyone,

My family bought a used prefabricated house (built in 2018) two months ago...

... And if so, is this considered a defect that the homeowner has five years to report to the construction company and request remediation?

From whom did you buy the house? From the company that assembled it? Probably not, right?

You can only successfully claim defects based on legal warranty rights if they fall within the warranty period, and you can enforce these only against your contractual partner.
Note: a warranty of title is not the same as a guarantee!

If your contractual partner (seller) is a private individual (the homeowner who had the house built in 2018), the governing factor is the contract with that person and how warranty claims are regulated there.

Without knowing the exact situation, it’s like playing blind man’s buff or fishing in murky waters.

Is it a structural defect or just a cosmetic one?
I seriously doubt that anything can still be enforced...

I took a closer look at the pictures (an additional photo from a greater distance would be even better). The ridge beam appears to be scarf jointed (the two laminated timber pieces), for whatever reason. Was there no suitable piece of KVH available? Extremely long roof structure. Who joints ridge beams in sections? No, no, no 🙄

Also, in my opinion, a metal bracket does not belong up there in a properly assembled roof frame.

As a solution, if you have doubts about the structural performance of the opposing rafters, a retrofitted, sufficiently strong (thick) collar beam might help. That could potentially straighten the rafters. However, a master carpenter would certainly be able to provide a better answer. But if I show this to someone (for example, the person who helped build our house), they always start swearing at such poor workmanship :p