ᐅ Basement and aerated concrete blocks – does it work?!

Created on: 10 Oct 2019 17:27
Q
quattro123
Hello everyone,

I am planning the construction of a house with a partially basemented area. The house is built on a slight slope, and the rear half directly adjoins the soil. This means the earth is exerting pressure on the house, and rainwater will likely flow toward the building.

So far, I have spoken with structural shell contractors who work with Poroton masonry. Without exception, they all immediately said that the area in contact with the soil should be formed with cast concrete. That seemed reasonable to me as well.

Recently, I visited someone who plans to build their entire house using a Ytong kit, and their colleague mentioned that it is also possible to build this area with Ytong blocks or that there are solutions available for that.

In general, my question is: What do you think about basements made from Ytong blocks? Are there specific Ytong systems designed for basement construction? Or should this approach be approached with caution?

What is interesting is that this colleague is a certified structural engineer and will definitely handle the structural calculations himself (we have done the plans with an architect who is supporting us through the building permit / planning permission process).

Best regards
P
Pamiko
18 Oct 2019 09:07
We are currently deciding whether to use an aerated concrete block or a Poroton T10 for our house.
Part of the basement will also be below ground level.
I plan to start a new thread soon, but based on this discussion, which block would you choose?
By the way, the Poroton is about €3000 more expensive.
M
Milo3
18 Oct 2019 09:44
Personally, I would build the basement only from concrete. Simply for the better peace of mind. However, it is certainly also a matter of cost. Concrete was by far the most expensive item for us (precast walls + reinforcement + concrete).
P
Pamiko
18 Oct 2019 09:58
Actually, my concern is only the choice between the two mentioned types of bricks. Other construction methods are not under consideration at all.
It is not a basement but a residential floor that is partially at ground level.
M
Milo3
18 Oct 2019 10:42
Then the portion on or below ground level is done in concrete. It tolerates occasional mistakes. The company is out of the picture after 5 years. However, damage usually only appears after 10 years...
B
Bookstar
18 Oct 2019 10:43
Always build ground-level structures in concrete, without exception. Any house built differently will sooner or later face problems, often within just a few years. I have personally experienced this three times and would like to help others avoid the same issues.
P
Pamiko
18 Oct 2019 10:47
As mentioned, it is not up for discussion.