ᐅ A genuine two-family house with similarly sized living areas

Created on: 13 May 2021 16:44
C
CleoBau
C
CleoBau
13 May 2021 16:44
Hello everyone,

First, our objectives and the facts, followed by our questions. We look forward to your feedback :-)

Thank you very much.

Objectives:
A two-family house designed for families with maximum functional use; optimal utilization of living space on the plot and adherence to the building regulations; equal living conditions for both households regarding natural light (south-facing living rooms, light wells for the basement) and comfort; compliance with KfW40 energy efficiency standards.

Building Regulations / Restrictions
Plot size: 810 m² (18x45 m (59x148 feet), rectangular, narrow side facing the street and aligned north/south; no trees, shrubs, etc.)
Neighboring buildings: Detached houses
Terrain: flat, no slope
Site coverage ratio (/building footprint ratio): 0.2, with a possible extension “up to a site coverage ratio of 0.5”
Floor area ratio: 0.4
Building envelope: 12x40 m (39x131 feet); building line and boundary: minimum 5.0 m (16 feet) distance between public road and main building or garages, and 3.0 m (10 feet) to every neighboring plot; maximum footprint of 120 m² (1,292 sq ft)
Edge development: no specification
Number of parking spaces: no specification
Number of floors: 2 full stories
Roof type: no requirement; in the street there are mansard roofs, gable roofs, hip roofs, and gambrel roofs
Architectural style: none specified; houses in the street vary from Italian-style cottages to brick bungalows
Orientation: not specified
Maximum heights / limits: base height max. 0.80 m (2.6 feet); eaves height max. 4.30 m (14 feet); ridge height max. 8.80 m (29 feet) measured to the nearest manhole cover (approximately standard curb depth, around 20 cm (8 inches))
Other requirements: tree planting on the plot, currently not relevant for the building design

Client Requirements
Style, roof type, building type: none specified, preferably mansard roof for better use of the attic
Basement, floors: fully finished and usable basement + 2 full stories + attic
Number of people, age group: 2 families with 1–3 children each
Space requirements on ground and upper floors: 120–140 m² (1,292–1,507 sq ft) per apartment
Guest rooms per year: one guest room per unit would be nice
Open or closed design: open design (3 m (10 feet) boundary to neighbor’s plot must be respected on both sides, if that is what is meant)
Conservative or modern design: target is KfW40, solid construction (not prefab)
Open kitchen, kitchen island: currently undecided
Number of dining places: 6–8 people
Fireplace: no, not planned
Balcony, roof terrace: terrace for one unit and balcony for the other
Garage, carport: double garage + 2 open parking spaces (possibly carport?) with electric vehicle charging stations
Other: no specific ideas yet, starting with what is feasible within the framework conditions

House Design
Who created the plan: self-made using Roomsketcher
What do you like and why?: large sliding doors from kitchen to living room to create a kind of open plan kitchen/living area, but can be closed to avoid cooking smells; bathrooms about 10 m² (108 sq ft) each for comfortable size; lower apartment should be barrier-free
What do you dislike and why?: staircase on the 1st floor to attic intrudes into the guest room, which is somewhat inconvenient
Cost estimate by architect/planner: I estimate about 520,000 €
Preferred heating technology: ground-source heat pump

If you had to give up on something, which details or extensions
- Could give up: mansard roof if the required two apartments with approx. 120 m² each can be achieved otherwise
- Cannot give up: 2 apartments with at least 4 rooms each

Why is the design as it is now?
Objective: We reviewed floor plans of prefab houses and based ours on those and our current apartment.

What is the most important/basic question regarding the floor plan in 130 characters?
Is my assumption about the site coverage ratio and building regulations correct?

Our questions:
  • Site coverage ratio: Plot area 810 m² (8,715 sq ft) with a site coverage ratio of 0.2 (=162 m² (1,743 sq ft)); limit: footprint for single-family house max. 120 m² (1,292 sq ft).
  • What can be included in the remaining 42 m² (452 sq ft) difference (balconies, bay windows, light wells, courtyards, terraces…)?
  • Extended site coverage ratio: for garages, etc., “site coverage ratio may be exceeded up to 0.5.” How is this calculated? Half of the plot area (405 m² (4,359 sq ft)), half of the plot area minus the original site coverage (405–162 = 243 m² (2,616 sq ft)), half of the site coverage ratio (81 m² (872 sq ft)), or half the footprint of the house (60 m² (646 sq ft))?
  • How are light wells (planted embankments, not attached cellar shafts) for basement illumination counted, under site coverage ratio or extended site coverage ratio?
  • How are balconies and overhanging bay windows counted?
  • What wall thicknesses should we expect for exterior walls (KfW40 standard with brick veneer) and interior walls?

Images attached:

Aerial view of a residential area with many houses, streets, and trees.


Bird’s-eye view: house floor plan with garden, terrace, parking spaces, and garage

Basement floor plan: guest room, children’s rooms, corridor, basement, utility room, laundry, staircase

Ground floor plan: living room, bedroom, children’s room, bathroom, corridor, staircase.

Upper floor plan: balcony, living room, kitchen, corridor, guest room, bathroom.

Attic floor plan with 4 rooms: 2 children’s rooms, bedroom, guest room, bathroom, stairs.
C
CleoBau
13 May 2021 16:50
I forgot to mention the other conditions: Wall thicknesses are currently planned at 465 mm (18 inches) on the outside and 240 mm (9.5 inches) on the inside. Ceiling heights are 2.5 m (8 feet 2 inches) on the ground floor and first floor, and slightly lower in the attic.
K
kbt09
13 May 2021 18:40
And forgetting to include the street and north arrow on the site plan....

However, everything will probably fail because of the staircase... Outside 404cm (159 inches) - wall thickness 93cm (37 inches) = 311cm (122 inches) available for the staircase, which remains the main traffic route (including furniture transport, kitchen countertops, etc.) for a two-family house.
H
haydee
13 May 2021 18:59
Why no duplex?
I don’t want to move into either of the two apartments. The light well does not provide natural daylight, and the terrace has no garden access.

Why should the ground floor be wheelchair accessible?
H
hanghaus2000
13 May 2021 19:09
Is there a zoning plan?

Please mark the plot of land on the aerial image.

A plan of the plot? Preferably from the geoportal. At least you can see where north is.

If it is a §34 case, then photos of the neighboring buildings are important.
C
Crossy
13 May 2021 20:17
I see four floors of 90sqm (970 sq ft) each? I would initially recommend getting information on construction costs. 520k is completely unrealistic for that.