ᐅ Is it possible to add dormer windows later on a solid roof structure (aerated concrete)?

Created on: 30 Aug 2024 13:46
J
J. Hasek
J
J. Hasek
30 Aug 2024 13:46
Dear and highly valued collective intelligence,

we are planning to buy a house built in 1992, which features a traditional gable roof with a solid roof structure made of aerated concrete. We are wondering whether it is possible, or feasible with reasonable effort, to retrofit dormers into the roof despite this solid construction.

I have very limited knowledge of real estate and, to be honest, apart from the sparse information I found online, I know almost nothing about a solid roof structure.

I assume that cutting into the aerated concrete on the roof slope would be very labor-intensive. I have already used the search function but unfortunately found nothing on this topic.

If anyone could share their knowledge or experience with this specific issue, I would be very grateful.

In any case, have a great Friday and a wonderful start to the weekend!

Best regards
N
nordanney
30 Aug 2024 13:56
In fact, I personally have no experience with an aerated concrete roof. However, a dormer should not be such a big issue here either when you look at the basic construction of this type of roof.
J. Hasek schrieb:

that cutting the concrete on the roof pitch is likely to be very labor-intensive.

Actually, that should be the easy part. You can easily cut aerated concrete with a bread knife. Very precise and simple.

Ytong’s website has a lot of information about solid roofs, where you can at least get the basic information.
11ant30 Aug 2024 20:12
J. Hasek schrieb:

I have already used the search function but unfortunately didn’t find anything on this topic.

As far as I remember, we haven’t discussed this here before (however, I only looked back one more year, even though I have taken two breaks lasting several months during the whole time).
J. Hasek schrieb:

We plan to buy a house built in 1992, which has a traditional gable roof with a solid roof structure made of aerated concrete. We are wondering whether it is possible, or feasible with reasonable effort, to install dormers in the roof afterwards despite this solid construction. [...] If anyone can offer advice on this specific issue based on their knowledge, I would be very grateful.

The manuals from Hebel and Ytong might provide some information, although they are aimed primarily at architects. The building file from 1992 should still be available. Is there already a dormer of this kind and you want to add more?
Are dormers actually meant, or rather "dormers" (cross-gables); what is the goal: more natural light or increased headroom?
The zoning plan (building permit / planning permission) can limit dormers and may even exclude cross-gables altogether.
https://www.instagram.com/11antgmxde/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/bauen-jetzt/
J
J. Hasek
30 Aug 2024 20:40
Thank you very much for both responses!
11ant schrieb:

Are dormers actually meant or rather “cross dormers” (gable dormers); what is the issue: light or gaining headroom?
The development plan can limit dormers and even exclude cross dormers entirely.

I’ve learned something new again—I didn’t even know the difference between a cross dormer and a dormer until just now. Thank you! I have the building plan available. The house is from Hebel and, based on a Wikipedia search about the difference, it has a cross dormer in the bathroom.
We are concerned with gaining headroom.
In the meantime, I have spoken with Hebel and Ytong, and the feedback I received aligns with the assessment by @nordanney that cutting into the aerated concrete roof structure is not a problem. However, greater challenges are expected and need to be addressed regarding structural engineering and thermal bridging. The overall assessment was “difficult, difficult, definitely more complex than with a traditional timber roof frame.”
Thank you all for the answers!
11ant31 Aug 2024 00:24
J. Hasek schrieb:

I have the building plan. The house is by Hebel and, according to a Wikipedia search on the difference, it has a dormer in the bathroom. We are interested in increasing the ceiling height.

If the house is "by Hebel" (meaning it is not built from Hebel blocks), I interpret this as a reference to a standardized model of a Hebel kit house; and you mention having the building plan. So, there is no need to guess, you can simply check. Please show the plan here and mark where the dormer is desired. Note: please share the entire plan (many questioners find it amusing to zoom in only on the section they are interested in, but that is not helpful and I will not engage in that). Then you have a good chance of receiving a recommendation for a solution.
https://www.instagram.com/11antgmxde/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/bauen-jetzt/
J
J. Hasek
31 Aug 2024 21:23
Dear @11ant,

Thank you very much for your contribution!
Since I have not yet purchased the house and only received the documents from the current owner, I prefer not to share them publicly online.
Because I have posted too little so far, I am currently unable to send you a private message; otherwise, I would have done so.
Nevertheless, many thanks for your time!

Best regards