ᐅ Asymmetric Facades as the Preferred Option?

Created on: 9 Oct 2021 20:51
I
In der Ruine
Hello everyone,

I have read several times that symmetrical facades are not particularly popular among experts.
What is the right degree of asymmetry? The golden ratio? The Fibonacci sequence?
What makes a building interesting, and do you have any examples?

I, of course, designed my extension to be perfectly symmetrical.


Front view of a house as a red architectural drawing with roof, windows, and entrance on the left.
In der Ruine12 Oct 2021 08:57
hampshire schrieb:

A consistent "form follows function" principle. This requires a thorough consideration of the goals the building is meant to achieve.

In our extension, there simply wasn’t much function. Two rooms, that’s it. The windows serve their purpose but shouldn’t be too small.
The side view has no windows because the walls are needed as space for furniture. In the new living room, I could have imagined "light slits" below the ceiling along the 5m (16 feet) side walls. It breaks the monotony of the side walls and brings a bit more light and openness.
hampshire schrieb:

What has no function is also not there. (Have a look at Bauhaus – after Gropius and his colleagues, not in sales brochures...)

That’s really not my style. I’m a fan of "the old," including "useless" decoration. Things used to be better 😉 and no cubes in the landscape.
hampshire schrieb:

I don’t understand the word "natural" in this sentence. Symmetry changes its appearance depending on the environment and the viewing angles.

"Natural" is intended negatively here. Sort of like, you should have done one, but out of ignorance did two, and then realize that one would have been better than two. It’s more of a rhetorical thing. Hard to explain. So it has nothing to do with naturalness.
hampshire schrieb:

If that really makes you happy, that’s good. But if you want to give your house something special also for others to appreciate visually, that’s not enough – and an architect can only help if their creativity has room to develop and is not limited by many fixed guidelines from the client.

Actually, we reflect the street view of the old building in the garden view of the extension. (see profile picture)

Thank you for your input.
In der Ruine12 Oct 2021 12:58
Since people often like to get unsettled, I took another look at the windows.

So, like in this example,

Interior with visible wooden beams, large window, and furniture during renovation

I find it quite elegant (except for the wood).

Instead of a window seat,

Bright bedroom with bed, window ledge seat, and wicker armchair

we would place a chaise lounge in front of one window and maybe a wider window sill for plants at the other.

Floor-to-ceiling windows are becoming less appealing to me.
Y
ypg
12 Oct 2021 13:22
In der Ruine schrieb:

Floor-to-ceiling windows are becoming less and less appealing to me.
Ok, I won’t bother you anymore 😉
(Plus a few characters…)
In der Ruine12 Oct 2021 13:32
ypg schrieb:

Ok, I won’t bother anymore 😉
(Plus some characters…)
You’re definitely not bothering. Thank you for your input, suggestions, and the time you invested.
S
Steffi33
12 Oct 2021 14:24
@In der Ruine I am a fan of symmetry, and I also don’t prefer windows that are not quite floor-to-ceiling. However, I get the impression that your window choices could be improved. The many panes make them look a bit old-fashioned. May I show you some of my adjustments… before and after?

Architekturzeichnung: Frontansicht eines Hauses mit Satteldach, roten Linien und Fenster.


Architektonische Zeichnung eines zweistöckigen Hauses mit Satteldach und vielen Fenstern.


Frontansicht eines roten Linienhauses mit Spitzdach, großen Fenstern und Seiteneingang


Rote Linienzeichnung einer Vorderansicht eines Hauses mit Satteldach, Fenstern und Eingang.


Architekturzeichnung eines roten Hauses mit Satteldach, Fenstern und Seiteneingang
In der Ruine12 Oct 2021 15:26
@Steffi33
Interesting idea. It’s something worth considering.
Wouldn’t the Scandinavian look be lost then?
Thank you for your effort.