ᐅ Floor plan of a 1.5-story house with a captain’s gable, covering just under 200 square meters
Created on: 18 Jul 2021 18:13
B
blubbernase
hi, we have been going back and forth with the work and wanted to get your opinion
Development Plan/Restrictions
Plot size: 673 m² (7239 ft²)
Slope: 3.5% incline from one side to the other
Floor area ratio: 0.2 (Floor area ratio I: 134.6 m² (1450 ft²), Floor area ratio II: 201.9 m² (2172 ft²))
Building envelope, building line and boundary: see picture (the side lines mark the property borders)
Edge development: new residential area, detached houses
Number of parking spaces: 1
Number of stories: max 1 full story
Roof type: gable roof
Architectural style: captain’s house
Orientation: ridge runs northwest to southeast
Maximum heights/limits: eaves height 4.5 m (15 ft), ridge height 9 m (30 ft), reference point in development plan nearly 1 meter (3 ft) above plot level, brick facing required, dormers allowed on only 50% of the eaves length
Client Requirements
Style, roof type, building type: gable roof
Basement, stories: partial unheated basement, ground floor, upper floor
Number of occupants, ages: 34 m, 33 f, 3 m, 4 f + 1 planned
Space needs on the ground floor: 1 office, 1 office/guest room, kitchen with dining area, living room, bathroom with shower, entry hall
Space needs on the upper floor: 1 bedroom, 3 children's rooms, 1 full bathroom, 1 toilet with washer/dryer
Office: 100% home office
Overnight guests per year: 1 per month, mother-in-law
Conservative or modern construction: practical?
Kitchen: kitchen with dining area, table to be inside the kitchen
Number of dining seats: 6
Fireplace: no
Music/sound wall: no
Balcony, roof terrace: no
Garage, carport: garage for one car and bicycles
Utility garden, greenhouse: maybe later
House Design
Ground floor: floor area 107.5 m² (1156 ft²) (including stairs)
Upper floor: floor area 101.2 m² (1090 ft²) (including stairs)
Basement: approx. 70 m² (753 ft²)
Designer: designed by ourselves using Sweet Home 3D
Basically, we based the exterior dimensions on the Whiteline promotional house "Kiefernallee" from Gussek Haus and extended it about 50 cm (20 inches) longer on the left side of the gable. We have been working with Gussek Haus for a while. Initially, we had a floor plan with 4 gables and a longer house, but we discarded it due to complexity. The upper-floor layout is still based on that promotional house, but the ground floor has changed quite a bit.
What do you particularly like? When entering the house, you’re not immediately in the living room.
Price estimate according to the architect/planner: base house approx. 450,000 € (including move-in ready) + 60,000 €
Personal price limit for the house including basement: 550,000 € + additional costs and fittings
Preferred heating system: air-to-water heat pump with indoor unit
If you had to give up something, which details/extensions?
- You could give up: basically nothing 😀
- You could not give up: a few extra square meters here and there
Why did the design turn out this way?
For example: it fits well on the plot, although the terrace is quite small.
What is the most important/fundamental question about the floor plan in 130 characters?
Will the long hallway annoy us despite being reasonably wide?









Development Plan/Restrictions
Plot size: 673 m² (7239 ft²)
Slope: 3.5% incline from one side to the other
Floor area ratio: 0.2 (Floor area ratio I: 134.6 m² (1450 ft²), Floor area ratio II: 201.9 m² (2172 ft²))
Building envelope, building line and boundary: see picture (the side lines mark the property borders)
Edge development: new residential area, detached houses
Number of parking spaces: 1
Number of stories: max 1 full story
Roof type: gable roof
Architectural style: captain’s house
Orientation: ridge runs northwest to southeast
Maximum heights/limits: eaves height 4.5 m (15 ft), ridge height 9 m (30 ft), reference point in development plan nearly 1 meter (3 ft) above plot level, brick facing required, dormers allowed on only 50% of the eaves length
Client Requirements
Style, roof type, building type: gable roof
Basement, stories: partial unheated basement, ground floor, upper floor
Number of occupants, ages: 34 m, 33 f, 3 m, 4 f + 1 planned
Space needs on the ground floor: 1 office, 1 office/guest room, kitchen with dining area, living room, bathroom with shower, entry hall
Space needs on the upper floor: 1 bedroom, 3 children's rooms, 1 full bathroom, 1 toilet with washer/dryer
Office: 100% home office
Overnight guests per year: 1 per month, mother-in-law
Conservative or modern construction: practical?
Kitchen: kitchen with dining area, table to be inside the kitchen
Number of dining seats: 6
Fireplace: no
Music/sound wall: no
Balcony, roof terrace: no
Garage, carport: garage for one car and bicycles
Utility garden, greenhouse: maybe later
House Design
Ground floor: floor area 107.5 m² (1156 ft²) (including stairs)
Upper floor: floor area 101.2 m² (1090 ft²) (including stairs)
Basement: approx. 70 m² (753 ft²)
Designer: designed by ourselves using Sweet Home 3D
Basically, we based the exterior dimensions on the Whiteline promotional house "Kiefernallee" from Gussek Haus and extended it about 50 cm (20 inches) longer on the left side of the gable. We have been working with Gussek Haus for a while. Initially, we had a floor plan with 4 gables and a longer house, but we discarded it due to complexity. The upper-floor layout is still based on that promotional house, but the ground floor has changed quite a bit.
What do you particularly like? When entering the house, you’re not immediately in the living room.
Price estimate according to the architect/planner: base house approx. 450,000 € (including move-in ready) + 60,000 €
Personal price limit for the house including basement: 550,000 € + additional costs and fittings
Preferred heating system: air-to-water heat pump with indoor unit
If you had to give up something, which details/extensions?
- You could give up: basically nothing 😀
- You could not give up: a few extra square meters here and there
Why did the design turn out this way?
For example: it fits well on the plot, although the terrace is quite small.
What is the most important/fundamental question about the floor plan in 130 characters?
Will the long hallway annoy us despite being reasonably wide?
Are you currently discussing the house with Gussek Haus as shown in the drawing? On the ground floor, mostly only the bark remains from the pine alley, but inside the beetles have made significant changes.
If the promotional house then costs around 450,000 (currency), that would probably be quite realistic. On top of that, there would be about 18 sqm (190 sq ft) more, an additional charge for custom design, and some details like a second bathroom. A (partial) basement would also be added with further processing according to the building permit / planning permission. I think the budget will at least be very tight.
The bathrooms upstairs probably force sitting while urinating, on the floor beyond a certain size 😉, offsets on the ground floor feel restless, and the entrance area seems out of place. Overall, I don’t find it particularly bright. The kitchen and dining table look more than cramped on the left side of the drawing, while there is a lot of free space in front of the patio door.
If the promotional house then costs around 450,000 (currency), that would probably be quite realistic. On top of that, there would be about 18 sqm (190 sq ft) more, an additional charge for custom design, and some details like a second bathroom. A (partial) basement would also be added with further processing according to the building permit / planning permission. I think the budget will at least be very tight.
The bathrooms upstairs probably force sitting while urinating, on the floor beyond a certain size 😉, offsets on the ground floor feel restless, and the entrance area seems out of place. Overall, I don’t find it particularly bright. The kitchen and dining table look more than cramped on the left side of the drawing, while there is a lot of free space in front of the patio door.
H
hanghaus200019 Jul 2021 13:34ypg schrieb:
https://www.hausbau-forum.de/threads/feedback-zu-unserer-grundstueckswahl-erwuenscht.37911/page-4
Take a look here. It should be about plot 27, where the neighbor’s driveways are each 2.50 m (8 feet 2 inches) wide.Thanks, I remembered that too. If the garage is built up to the boundary, will the fire department access for the neighbor to the north be too narrow?
The bay window tells me that we definitely need an architect here. I can’t figure out how the garage would work in this layout.
B
blubbernase19 Jul 2021 14:47Hi, thanks for the feedback. Sorry, I forgot to link the old thread. Thanks for adding it.
The house I was referring to wasn’t the standard Kiefernalley, but the one under "Promotions" and then "KFW Special Series," specifically the Kiefernalley house. The upper floor just got a second bathroom added. Last night before going to bed, we also found the Sanderau promotional house from Gussek Haus (easily found by googling), which has an almost identical upper floor layout (instead of a gallery, a third kids’ room) and a more compact right side on the ground floor. We just don’t know if you can fit a shower bathroom, a second office, and a small entrance hall (mudroom/windfang) in there.
We’ve already agreed with the neighbors not to put any fences along about 15 meters (49 ft) of the driveway so they can access their driveways more easily, which makes the situation a bit more relaxed.
Thanks for the feedback, but honestly, it’s hard for me to take anything concrete from this besides "go to an architect."
The house I was referring to wasn’t the standard Kiefernalley, but the one under "Promotions" and then "KFW Special Series," specifically the Kiefernalley house. The upper floor just got a second bathroom added. Last night before going to bed, we also found the Sanderau promotional house from Gussek Haus (easily found by googling), which has an almost identical upper floor layout (instead of a gallery, a third kids’ room) and a more compact right side on the ground floor. We just don’t know if you can fit a shower bathroom, a second office, and a small entrance hall (mudroom/windfang) in there.
driver55 schrieb:The stairs are included in the calculation.
(Or are the 12 sqm stairs included? Then it would be 42 sqm including living area) The rest is like in a (poorly laid out) 150 sqm house.
driver55 schrieb:How do you get 270 m²?
(270 sqm vs. 550k€ max)
driver55 schrieb:There aren’t many goals. We have 134.6 m² (1450 sq ft) of area that we can cover with house and terrace. Upper floor: 1 bedroom, 3 kids’ rooms, 1 full bathroom, one functional WC where the dryer and washing machine can also be placed, and a small storage room. Ground floor: open-plan kitchen and living room, shower bathroom, 2 offices (one as a guest room), plus entrance hall (windfang). The kitchen should face the front, as should the small office.
First, the target needs to be clarified or "cleaned up."
ypg schrieb:Do you happen to know where?
A similar floor plan has been discussed here before…
ypg schrieb:That’s actually our pro argument. All those layouts where you can look straight at the couch or coffee table from the entrance are an absolute no-go for us. Or having to walk through the front yard to get to the upper floor every evening because the staircase is right at the entrance — no thanks.
Personally, it feels too closed off to me. Too long a corridor to the living spaces.
ypg schrieb:We are aware of that, but in our current detached house, we have a small one like that and we find it great.
The pantry with barely 60 cm (24 inches) depth corresponds to a tall kitchen cabinet.
ypg schrieb:The knee wall height is planned at about 130 cm (51 inches), and there will be Velux windows above the toilets, so that should counteract the issue.
Bathrooms on the upper floor are probably disqualified due to the sloping ceiling?
K1300S schrieb:They are small coat racks for the kids, I think from Ikea.
What are those colored blocks in the entrance hall?
K1300S schrieb:We contacted 15 architects in our target region in March with detailed requirements, got 7 responses, 5 had no availability until at least October, and of the two we talked to, one complained that we had too many specific wishes and the other just wasn’t a good fit for us.
Go to an architect, but WITHOUT these scribbles.
borxx schrieb:Not explicitly about this new design, but the last ones, yes. We haven’t signed a contract yet, so no architect from their side is involved; once everything is signed, detailed planning will begin. The exterior dimensions are more important at this point.
Are you currently talking with Gussek Haus about the house as drawn here? The Kiefernalley is mostly still just the shell on the ground floor, but internally they've done a lot of redesigning.
borxx schrieb:Don’t worry about that; I already have two offers based on two concrete designs, and they were all within budget.
If the promotional house costs around 450k€, that would be quite realistic. Then there would be about 18 sqm (194 sq ft) more, extra costs for custom planning and some details like the second bathroom. (Partial) basement is also additional with work on the building permit/planning permission. I think it will be quite tight financially.
borxx schrieb:The knee wall is about 130 cm (51 inches), and Velux windows will be above the toilets, so that should avoid that problem. Also, the bathrooms are not that big.
The upper bathrooms probably force you to sit to pee, or otherwise to squat on the floor 😉,
hanghaus2000 schrieb:The arched window is only there because we wanted a large window, and the tool we’re using didn’t support anything else. We’ll have to see how it really looks during the final fittings. We have a preliminary fittings appointment on Friday.
The arched window tells me you definitely need an architect here. How the garage is supposed to fit doesn’t make sense to me.
hanghaus2000 schrieb:Hmm, good point. I need to talk to the neighbors. The driveway is 3 meters (10 ft) at the entrance and 4 meters (13 ft) wide afterwards, so it should be fine.
If the garage is on the boundary, is the fire access road for the neighbor to the north too narrow?
We’ve already agreed with the neighbors not to put any fences along about 15 meters (49 ft) of the driveway so they can access their driveways more easily, which makes the situation a bit more relaxed.
borxx schrieb:The table already exists; we tested the measurements, and it fits.
Kitchen and dining table look more than tight on the left side in the drawing,
Thanks for the feedback, but honestly, it’s hard for me to take anything concrete from this besides "go to an architect."
blubbernase schrieb:
but the detailed planning only starts once everything is signed. That surprises me quite a lot. You haven’t just joined recently, so you should know that this is exactly the wrong sequence. Of course, you can — and will — still make adjustments and changes after signing, but major issues like an additional bathroom or a partial basement need to be resolved before signing.
blubbernase schrieb:
"go to the architect" I can only repeat myself here. 😉 It doesn’t have to be a freelance architect, but starting by buying a standard house and defining custom requests later doesn’t seem very sensible to me. I can tell you that our contact with Gussek Haus was similar, which is why we decided against this provider due to the many unresolved questions that were to be clarified “later.” It can definitely be done differently and better.
The budget will probably not be sufficient for an all-in price at this time.
Do you have a quote for the basement including disposal?
Do you have all the additional construction costs?
Do you have all the costs that are specified as the client’s responsibility in the scope of work?
Do you have all the costs that will arise but are not listed in the scope of work?
What is the standard described in the scope of work? From electrical installations to tiling and the front door?
Does this match your expectations?
Draw a 2 m (6.5 ft) line on the floor plan.
Large entrance hall – little space for a coat rack
Small pantry – every cupboard adds more storage space. You still have a basement, right?
Kitchen is not very ergonomic
Dining area – how wide is it?
Kitchen is relatively far from the terrace
On the upper floor:
Bedroom has hardly any storage space
Toilets are probably not suitable for tall people
Very large hallway
Where will the dirty laundry be collected?
I didn’t like the original plan, and in my view, this is an attempted improvement that has actually made things worse.
Do you have a quote for the basement including disposal?
Do you have all the additional construction costs?
Do you have all the costs that are specified as the client’s responsibility in the scope of work?
Do you have all the costs that will arise but are not listed in the scope of work?
What is the standard described in the scope of work? From electrical installations to tiling and the front door?
Does this match your expectations?
Draw a 2 m (6.5 ft) line on the floor plan.
Large entrance hall – little space for a coat rack
Small pantry – every cupboard adds more storage space. You still have a basement, right?
Kitchen is not very ergonomic
Dining area – how wide is it?
Kitchen is relatively far from the terrace
On the upper floor:
Bedroom has hardly any storage space
Toilets are probably not suitable for tall people
Very large hallway
Where will the dirty laundry be collected?
I didn’t like the original plan, and in my view, this is an attempted improvement that has actually made things worse.
blubbernase schrieb:
How do you arrive at 270 m² (2,906 sq ft)?blubbernase schrieb:
House design
Ground floor: footprint 107.5 m² (including stairs)
Upper floor: footprint 101.2 m² (including stairs)
Basement: approx. 70 m² (approx. 753 sq ft)[/U] Furthermore, I gather from your responses: “Everything is wonderful, this is how we’ll build.” 😳
All I can say is “Help.”
Similar topics