ᐅ Insulation damaged by excavation work. Serious issue?

Created on: 7 Nov 2020 17:33
G
gamer456
Hello everyone,

We are building our single-family house through a general contractor. Today, I noticed that the perimeter insulation was damaged during the excavation work (see attachment 1). Is this a serious issue?

Additionally, a studded membrane layer was installed on top of the perimeter insulation. It was attached to the perimeter insulation at certain points. Is this correct? As a result, many stones fell between the perimeter insulation and the studded membrane during the excavation work. Is this a problem?

Thank you very much.

Riss in blauem Untergrund, sichtbare hellblaue Innenschicht; Kiesboden daneben.


Nahaufnahme eines schwarzen Metallrahmens im Bau mit Erde und Kies neben einer hellblauen Fläche.


Graue Bau-Linerwand in einer Baugrube; aus dem Boden ragt ein schwarzes Rohr, Kies und Erde.
B
Bookstar
8 Nov 2020 11:53
danixf schrieb:

If there is a large stone in between and it presses into the insulation, the effectiveness is lost.
The correct approach would be to remove the dimpled membrane once and check, but probably no one will agree to that.
But only in that one spot. That would be manageable. However, if there are several spots, damp areas could develop in the basement.
D
danixf
8 Nov 2020 12:32
gamer456 schrieb:

In addition, a dimpled membrane layer was installed on top of the perimeter insulation. This membrane was attached to the perimeter insulation at specific points. Is this correct? The consequence is that during excavation work, many stones fell between the perimeter insulation and the dimpled membrane. Is this a problem?

I understood this to mean that stones fell in at several spots. The original poster might need to clarify whether the stones are only in one location or spread everywhere.
G
gamer456
8 Nov 2020 12:57
danixf schrieb:

I understood it as stones having fallen in at several spots.. the original poster will need to clarify whether they are only in one place or spread out everywhere.

Not at all locations – only in a few spots. Where the excavator operator didn’t work carefully.

Also, there is direct damage to the dimple membrane and the insulation. Is that less serious than the stones?
D
danixf
8 Nov 2020 13:16
gamer456 schrieb:

Not everywhere – just in a few spots. Where the excavator operator didn’t work carefully.

Also, there are direct damages to the dimple membrane and the insulation. Is that not as serious as the stones?

The dimple membrane is only a mechanical protection layer. If it has some minor damage in a few spots, it’s usually not a problem. As for the insulation, it depends on the size of the damage. If a fist-sized stone has pushed into it, I would consider replacing that section.

I would have addressed the excavator operator myself. You can easily cut off the last 5cm (2 inches) of soil by hand with a spade instead of experimenting with the excavator bucket in that area.